jeffrey st. clair: israel's attack on the uss liberty, revisited

jeffrey st. clair: israel's attack on the uss liberty, revisited home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events / faq exclusive to counterpunch newsletter subscribers! the democrats bow to bush on war: how the anti-war movement failed alexander cockburn picks through the rubble after dems vote war funds. wars inside america: eyewitness reports from andrea peacock amid a migra raid in arizona and from george corsetti amid gunfire in the collapsing city of detroit. get your copy today by subscribing online or calling 1-800-840-3683 remember contributions to counterpunch are tax-deductible. click here to make a donation. if you find our site useful please: subscribe now order counterpunch by email for only $35 a year and receive a free copy of "imperial crusades: a diary of three wars" by cockburn and st. clair cool clothes for a hot summer: brand new counterpunch t-shirts! today's stories june 8, 2007 serge halimi what sarkozy learned about politics from the us june 7, 2007 marjorie cohn the prison is the war crime soldz, reisner and olson: a q & a on psychologists and torture soldz, reisner and olson, et al: an open letter to sharon brehm, president of the american psychological association paul craig roberts losing iraq, nuking iran bill quigley "how long must we support a mistake?" silvia cattori sailing to gaza carl g. estabrook what the june bug is: politics in the dismal season ellen taylor free the tweakers!: the good news about meth corporate crime reporter bae systems, prince bandar and the $2 billion account at the riggs bank brenda norrell torture training at ft. huachuca: two priests face prison for exposing torture in arizona d. k. wilson what gary sheffield really said kevin zeese iraq occupation coming to a head over oil website of the day how the press expired june 6, 2007 alain gresh countdown to war on iran gary leupp poddy's crazy prayer: bomb iran, for israel and america! steven sherman the perils of humanitarian intervention bruce dixon is bill gates trying to hijack africa's food supply? corporate crime reporter the professor and the nukes brian m. downing the iraq war and presidential politics ron jacobs luv n' hate: a different take on the summer of love george bisharat the mirage of the two state solution nicole colson over to you, dante: falwell's ministry of hate bruce k. gagnon from italy to guam: a global peace movement is taking shape website of the day how the democrats should treat bush   june 5, 2007 michael neumann canada in afghanistan jonathan cook the shin bet and the persecution of azmi bishara david vest the democrats' war robert fantina america's cuba policy hoffman, parsneau and chowdhury counterterrorism as international healthcare john v. walsh shaming the official antiwar movement richard cretan yellow dog: the strange love of martin amis and tony blair adam engel days of dread: an american tale william s. lind the news from anbar: has al qaeda over-reached? myles hoenig free the oaks! cut down those yellow ribbons! jim minick lead-foot nation website of the day punk rock soap opera june 4, 2007 nizar latif an interview with moqtada al-sadr diana johnstone sarko and the ghosts of may, 1968 gregory wilpert rctv and freedom of speech in venezuela paul watson the anchorage whale killing bureaucrats summit susan rosenthal, md how cindy sheehan unmasked the democrats richard ward the right of return to new orleans eva liddell don't support the troops zahi khouri four decades of occupation evelyn pringle the fda, glaxosmithkline and the avandia disaster china hand about those north korean benjamin franklins ... karyn strickler george w. bush: a "ficeist" leader website of the day the guantanamo files   june 2 / 3, 2007 alexander cockburn the last of the texas outsiders marc levy iraq dead ahead: a brief military history and civilian guide to arlington national cemetery martin smith camilo mejía's war: from foot soldier for empire to rebel for peace diana johnstone great power meddling in kosovo john ross the oaxaca volcano stews uri avnery on generals and admirals sunsara taylor this is not a story about cindy sheehan richard neville were the hippies right? p. sainath the farm crisis and 100,000 indian widows missy comley beattie let's roar nisrine abiad and victor kattan the hariri tribunal: a fait accompli? rannie amiri lebanon, bush and the three stooges margot pepper deconstructing "return to sender" eric stewart censorship and cop brutality in the new bison wars ralph nader the halberstam camp dan bacher a victory for the fish shaun harkin and sandy boyer irish war protesters on trial richard rhames selling five acres in crawford frederick hudson the rediscovery of ella fitzgerald poets' basement lindorff, landau and buknatski website of the weekend gimme shelter june 1, 2007 dave marsh the fbi and the godfather (of soul): james brown's fbi files saul landau return to cuba: 47 years later in havana david phinney how the baghdad embassy was built: forced labor and worker abuse robert jensen the bigot and the boycott stanley heller arrest robert mcnamara yifat susskind indigenous women fight back robert weissman corporate power since 1980 paul buchheit africa and its discontents william s. lind the folly of maximalist objectives sherwood ross 78,000 iraqis have been killed by coalition airstrikes stephen lendman terrorism defined website of the day desert autonomous zone may 31, 2007 robert bryce the language barrier patrick cockburn killing with impunity: iraq's militias under the surge gary leupp appropriate disillusionment: the despair of cindy sheehan and andrew bacevich kathy kelly being hope marjorie cohn the unitary king george chris kutalik and tiffany ten eyck fallout from the sale of chrysler: jobs, health care, pensions, all in jeopardy corporate crime reporter zheng xiaoyu meet lester crawford dave lindorff our monica: a hero of the constitution website of the day know your rights!   may 30, 2007 james ridgeway the bi-partisan con on synthetic fuels franklin lamb lebanon and the planned us airbase at kaleiaat terrence e. paupp withdrawal symptoms uri avnery to the shores of tripoli alan maass and jeffrey st. clair the green masquerade: corporate america's latest counter-attack rock and rap confidential watching the detectives: the political censorship of hip hop ralph nader taming the giant corporation nirmal ghosh china, cites and the fate of the tiger jean daniels dealing democrats: folding to mr. 28% tom barry meet robert zoellick: bush's pick to head world bank website of the day petuuche gilbert on the rights of indigenous people may 29, 2007 stephen soldz shrinks and the sere technique at guantanamo eliza ernshire refugees forever: inside bedawi camp ron jacobs the exit of cindy sheehan dave lindorff whatever happened to signing statements? evelyn pringle what qualifies bush to lead iraq war mike whitney bush's new middle east david swanson how we got here: the democrats and the antiwar movement john holt gating montana, part two: the feedback loop cynthia mckinney dreaming of a true memorial day martha rosenberg mad cows, mad pigs and the horse slaughter lobby website of the day the ruminant may 28, 2007 bill quigley katrina activists: "less meeting, more fighting" col. dan smith the paranoid and the dead cindy sheehan why i am leaving the democratic party dr. susan block dr. laura's little monster jeeni criscenzo what i learned about being a dickhead douglas valentine memorial day: a poem website of the day peace tv     may 26 / 27, 2007 alexander cockburn the greenhousers strike back and out michael donnelly green sabotage as "terrorism" patrick cockburn sadr's dramatic reappearance franklin lamb inside nahr el-bared: "another waco in the making" jean bricmont the moral collapse of the moral left gary leupp cheney, israel and iran james petras imperial rot: the beginning of the end of the american empire? william peace ashley unlawfully sterilized judith and john sharpe the saga of our son, lt. commander john sharpe: under investigation for antiwar sentiments saul landau four dead in ohio: from kent state to tiannamen square paul craig roberts democracy in iraq, tyranny at home? jonathan m. feldman congress and the iraq war vote dave lindorff democratic blood money missy beattie congress plays dead mike whitney swan song of the democrats badruddin khan aipac intervenes on iran and congress folds, again ron jacobs the crime of silence zoe blunt the antidote to despair arjun chowdhury, mark hoffman and kevin parsneau the can-do troops and the new anti-politics heather gray the 1969 riots against the chinese in malaysia: a new explanation n. d. jayaprakash disarmament negotiations: a history and prospectus joe allen and paul d'amato cartoons with class poets' basement gowani, ford, anderson and simon website of the weekend addicted to war may 25, 2007 robert jensen what the finkelstein tenure fight tells us about the state of academia david vest so you thought they'd end the war john stauber democratic spin won't end the war in iraq evelyn pringle congress gives war profiteers another $100 billion corporate crime reporter why corporate social responsibility programs are a fraud susan rosenthal, md what's missing from the health care debate roberto rodriguez us vs. them in the immigration debate steve fournier goodie, goodie goodling patrick mcelwee venezuela and rctv: is free speech really at stake? robert weissman resisting the commercialization of public schools website of the day new dnc motto: "we suck"     may 24, 2007 franklin lamb who's behind the fighting in north lebanon corporate crime reporter house democrats buckle to big oil: strip down price gouging bill robert fantina giuliani: righteous, indignant and wrong norman solomon deadly illusions, rest in peace dave lindorff kerrycrats all!: now it's a democratic war sen. russell feingold we are moving backwards on iraq fred gardner doctor of last resort mike whitney paulson in china kevin parsneau, arjun chowdhury and mark hoffman becoming imperialist: a warning to iraq war critics caroline paul my brother the "terrorist": animal liberation and prosecutorial overkill eva liddell in defense of lying on job applications website of the day johnny's jumped the shark may 23, 2007 patrick cockburn opium: iraq's newest export rev. william alberts faith-based imperialism joe deraymond colombia's civil war and the us sudhanva deshpande and vijay prashad the political economy of a crisis paul craig roberts republicans in self-destruct mode glen ford a less "white" usa rannie amiri the great bank heist of tripoli china hand china's great wall of cash? zoe blunt tales from the tree tops: veteran tree sitter tells all nivien saleh who's to blame for iraq? website of the day debating the israel lobby may 22, 2007 robert fisk a front row seat for the bloodbath in lebanon joshua frank hillary clinton's achilles heel? harvey wasserman drop dead, new yorkers: giuliani and the toxic fallout from 9/11 david mos masumoto an orchard without workers sonja karkar israeli forest named after australian prime minister conn hallinan the afghan quagmire dave lindorff a widening chasm on impeachment jeffrey kolakowski meet us in detroit: an open letter to john konyers evelyn pringle a misleading suicide warning jim baumer politics gary, indiana-style website of the day should the democrats fear mike gravel? may 21, 2007 patrick cockburn the secret us plot to kill sadr nicole colson much ado about the fort dix pizza plot john ross shooting for the top: mexico's drug gangs take aim at calderon stephen fleischman werewolf of washington: wolfowitz comes full circle m. shahid alam chosenness and israeli exceptionalism ron jacobs green mountain days: return to vermont peter rost, md pfizer cfo resigns alan farago can the everglades save florida? paul buchheit the dark side of democracy promotion website of the day code monkey: live! may 19 / 20, 2007 andrew cockburn why america lost the war in iraq uri avnery the next war peter gelderloos my arrest in spain: the easy road from tourism to terrorism saul landau bush's accomplishments robert fantina iraq's history: lessons for the present and the future fred gardner hemp vs. pot, a false dichotomy ralph nader timid democrats and the antiwar movement jean daniels waiting for obama reza fiyouzat vietnam syndrome: dead or alive? missy beattie ron paul, rudy giuliani and osama's fatwah robert alvarez magical thinking about nuclear waste sonja karkar the palestinians of iraq dave lindorff mumia case on hold jeff sher keep workers healthy and reduce health care cost: eliminate co-pays julian c. holmes torture, maine style clancy sigal red mutiny: 11 fateful days on the battleship potemkin prairie miller the murder of fred hampton james murren the dog ate karl rove's homework: when turd blossom met the teachers of the year poets' basement davies, valentine and engel website of the weekend yellowstone's shame: harassing newborn bison   may 18, 2007 adam jones when does genocide purify? ask the pope sharon smith the death of triangulation politics? christopher brauchli cheney's middle east adventure peter rost, md bribes and spies in the drug industry denise maloney pictou the murder of our mother, anna mae pictou aquash: after 31 years, it is time for justice david swanson of snoops and dupes ali khan the lawyers' mutiny in pakistan susan rosenthal, m.d. cho seung-hui delivers his message samer assad israel and the refugees: fifty-nine years of dispossession cp news service bidding for extinction: ivory trade on ebay threatens survival of elephants website of the day another war criminal goes to harvard   may 17, 2007 tariq ali the general vs. the judge yifat susskind honor killings in the new iraq: the murder of du'a aswad dave zirin being ali or being owned: an open letter to lebron james brian j. foley hell, no, harry won't go! w. john green the godfather of colombia: uribe and the para scandal eric johnson-debaufre challenges for the new sanctuary movement badruddin khan rebirthing the neocons: bernard lewis' latest call to arms martha rosenberg from cockfighting to foie gras: on the menu and on the docket china hand pope rat in brazil: "the amazon tribes longed for christianity!" dan vojir falwell's tinky winky legacy: who will battle the telebubby threat now? website of the day welcome to the terrordome may 16, 2007 patrick cockburn chalabi speaks ashley dawson who's afraid of wolfowitz? joshua frank obama's cash flow: maverick or kidder? corporate crime reporter corporate drug pushers ray mcgovern a four-letter word for tenet glen ford black labor and the big mission joe bageant the ghosts of timothy leary and hunter s. thompson sonja karkar the 59-year catastrophe mickey s. huff preaching hate: farewell, falwell john chuckman falwell's lone act of kindness kaz dziamka what ever happened to rogerian argument? website of the day we're all going to hell   may 15, 2007 michael neumann two states, one state and snake oil patrick cockburn an american nightmare ashley smith how the us set iraq on fire marc gardner parole and the long-distance trucker dave lindorff and linn washington, jr mumia case reaches its climax ben terrall benchmark as theft: iraq oil workers strike to stop privatization ron jacobs cheney threatens more war harvey wasserman the legacy of seabrook marcus mabry shopping during katrina dr. susan block cheney and the dc madam's cookie jar website of the day save jean klock park from the mega-developers!   may 14, 2007 jennifer roesch giuliani time: the mussolini of manhattan jeffrey st. clair humans, co2 and climate change george bisharat for palestinians, memory matters diane wachtell the real imus lesson ramzy baroud from palestine to rotterdam rosemary and walter brasch when the national guard goes missing: an ill wind and american policy nafeez mosaddeq ahmed blair's exit roberto rodriguez the elusive bars of justice jonathan culp cutting out collage: copyright and art in canada website of the day uranium rock may 12 / 13, 2007 alexander cockburn who are the merchants of fear? patrick cockburn state of surge jeffrey st. clair high line fever: a trip across the dark side of montana diane farsetta untold stories from the pat tillman / jessica lynch hearings ralph nader strip mining the newsroom: mr. zell and the tribune company jean bricmont the great illusion: sarkozy and the "decline" of france marcus breen cheering sarkozy: the us media and the rightwing takeover of france joe bageant rising above politics conn hallinan european missiles and the camel's nose fred gardner the unreported i-880 fire juan santos and leslie radford public terror: escalating the war on migrants eve bachrach inside colombia's flower industry missy comley beattie shame ron jacobs the bitterness of regis debray niranjan ramakrishnan the sepoy mutiny after 150 years susie day jesus christ weds pat robertson poets' basement newberry, engel, landau, katz and davies website of the weekend the shipyard: recycling as art may 11, 2007 patrick cockburn blair's depature: the view from baghdad kathleen christison playing at peace mike ferner collateral genocide john holt gating montana: a ghastly disneyland with high rise outhouses laurie hasbrook this minute and then the next: a plea from an antiwar mother christopher brauchli the children of limbo: will the pope finally set them free? margaret kimberley gop openly embraces gipper values: racism, violence and control dave lindorff use it or lose it: the democrats and the impeachment clause nicole colson anger erupts at conditions in for-profit indiana prison john v. walsh beware the do-gooders in body armor website of the day take the terrorist quiz!   may 10, 2007 tariq ali adieu, blair, adieu patrick cockburn killing of teachers turns iraqi sunnis against al--qa'ida neve gordon and yigal bronner in israel not all blood is the same: the death of samir dari marjorie cohn fighting terror selectively: washington and posada carriles david rosen the new disappeared: sex offenders, civil confinement and the resurrection of "evil" alan farago why the everglades have dried up: developers and the south florida drought john hellman france: from pétain to sarkozy kathy rentenbach a 100 days of rafael correa banco the stage is set for sentencing another innocent black man richard rhames is paris burning? website of the day tame the corporation may 9, 2007 jeff leys iraq and afghanistan supplemental spending, 2008 patrick cockburn an interview with iraq's foreign minister on iran and iraq glen ford no black plan for america's cities paula rothenberg feminism then and now kathryn weber a conversation with norman finkelstein john chuckman the likely historical significance of the war in iraq jordan flaherty looking for justice in jena, louisiana dave lindorff pelosi's toothless threat to sue bush stephen lendman criminalizing speech: the war on free expression in a post-9/11 world website of the day "fifth and market": a short film about the iraq war     may 8, 2007 dave lindorff the great oil robbery patrick cockburn the horrific stoning death of a yazidi girl sparks waves of revenge killings corporate crime reporter snuff politics: democrats escalate attack on single payer ralph nader the people's crusade of mike gravel malini johar schueller decoding harlan ullman: shock and awe as sexual fantasy juan santos the hate equation: targeting migrant children in la dave zirin jason whitlock, the clarence thomas of sportswriters? joshua frank the price of fire in latin america evelyn pringle serotonin syndrome eamonn mccann irish peace dividend for discredited premiers website of the day the pagan science monitor     may 7, 2007 patrick cockburn the great wall of baghdad rises monica benderman land of opportunity greg moses hutto prison rebuffs un rapporteur rannie amiri the sham at sheikh: iraq regional conference a flop fitrakis / wasserman media silence on kent state revelations fred wilhelms another royalty forfeiture from soundexchange: and this time it's secret! ramzy baroud the hourglass of blood: darfur revisited bruce k. gagnon the democrats don't own the antiwar movement t. w. croft home movies from a weekend in paris--and related dreamscapes sonja karkar prizes for supporting israel? website of the day posada carriles: the declassified record may 5 / 6, 2007 alexander cockburn trying to catch up with the voters william blum how america has changed iraq uri avnery exercise in escapism franklin lamb harvard's twisted report on israel's invasion of lebanon fred gardner elective surgeries kill lawrence r. velvel the american moral meltdown accelerates missy beattie lying and dying: the moral sensibility of military recruiters robert fantina bush's veto: hypocritical words and actions carla blank american massacres and the media linn washington, jr. the long ordeal of harold wilson stephen f. jackson taking it to drummond: paramilitaries and mining companies in colombia p. sainath the jailing of indian farmers anthony papa time to end new york's war on itself james t. phillips blather cancer john ross last days of the willie loman of the ezln stephen lendman chavez's oil policy sparks panic at wall street journal ben terrall iggy pop at 60 counterpunch newswire advice from a geezer assassin poets' basement valentine, engel and davies website of the weekend mountain justice summer   may 4, 2007 patrick cockburn how the surge is failing col. dan smith from watergate to gonzogate norman solomon fox on wall street azmi bishara why is israel after me? ron jacobs sitting in on senator kohl and the war dave lindorff clinton and byrd are calling for revocation of the wrong aumf kevin zeese the democrats cave to bush bob fitrakis why four died in ohio: kent state, gov. rhodes and the fbi janet kauffman "stop the mudness!" bare earth is scorched earth website of the day let us gather in missouri!   may 3, 2007 jeff halper the livni-rice plan for the middle east: a just peace or apartheid? christopher brauchli bush's best and brightest: from dr. keroack to bernard kerik dave zirin talking sports from death row: an interview with kevin cooper corporate crime reporter big pharma gets its hooks into seton hall law school robert fisk olmert comes undone mike ferner bush veto, right for the wrong reasons? mike whitney a stock market post-mortem pham binh the democrats and war funding dave lindorff kucinich's impeachment train: look who just stepped aboard michael a. johnson tenet on 60 minutes website of the day olivia wilde: the interview   may 2, 2007 saul landau would jesus wear a rolex on his tv show? dr. susan block hookergate ii: madame julia's big black book of cheesy republican sex acts carla blank historical amnesia: worst u.s. massacre? margaret kimberly the candor of mike gravel: "these people frighten me" kevin zeese durbin gives edwards more to apologize for carlos villareal how "law and order" covers for bigotry in the immigration debate michael dickinson trouble in turkey: criminalizing political art tim shorrock a raw deal between washington and seoul: corporate interventionism as trade policy alevtina rea the myth-makers of estonia william s. lind general incompetence: col. yingling and the military brass website of the day good news: rost's "zubegate exposé prompts congressional inquiry may 1, 2007 andrew cockburn how rumsfeld micromanaged torture fred gardner affirmative abstinence: adios, randall tobias, the man who turned his wife's suicide into a sales pitch for prozac chase madar are working class jobs bad for your health? ralph nader cheney and the byu 25: faith, accountability and protest in utah john v. walsh edgy dems snarl at their antiwar base joshua frank obama, incorporated leslie radford the migrant trap and the migrant's way out shaun harkin an interview with nativo lópez on immigration bills and protests dave lindorff murtha talks impeachment peter rost, md inspector general requests meeting with pfizer whistleblower peter linebaugh may day and magna carta website of the day impeachment? why bother?         subscribe online june 8, 2007   rockets, napalm, torpedoes & lie israel's attack on the uss liberty, revisited by jeffrey st. clair in early june of 1967, at the onset of the six day war, the pentagon sent the uss liberty from spain into international waters off the coast of gaza to monitor the progress of israel's attack on the arab states. the liberty was a lightly armed surveillance ship. only hours after the liberty arrived it was spotted by the israeli military. the idf sent out reconnaissance planes to identify the ship. they made eight trips over a period of three hours. the liberty was flying a large us flag and was easily recognizable as an american vessel. a few hours later more planes came. these were israeli mirage iii fighters, armed with rockets and machine guns. as off-duty officers sunbathed on the deck, the fighters opened fire on the defenseless ship with rockets and machine guns. a few minutes later a second wave of planes streaked overhead, french-built mystere jets, which not only pelted the ship with gunfire but also with napalm bomblets, coating the deck with the flaming jelly. by now, the liberty was on fire and dozens were wounded and killed, excluding several of the ship's top officers. the liberty's radio team tried to issue a distress call, but discovered the frequencies had been jammed by the israeli planes with what one communications specialist called "a buzzsaw sound". finally, an open channel was found and the liberty got out a message to the uss america, the sixth fleet's large aircraft carrier, that it was under attack two f-4s left the carrier to come to the liberty's aid. apparently, the jets were armed only with nuclear weapons. when word reached the pentagon, defense secretary robert mcnamara became irate and ordered the jets to return. "tell the sixth fleet to get those aircraft back immediately," he barked. mcnamara's injunction was reiterated in saltier terms by admiral david l. mcdonald, the chief of naval operations: "you get those fucking airplanes back on deck, and you get them back down." the planes turned around. and the attack on the liberty continued. after the israeli fighter jets had emptied their arsenal of rockets, three israeli attack boats approached the liberty. two torpedoes were launched at the crippled ship, one tore a 40-foot wide hole in the hull, flooding the lower compartments, and killing more than a dozen american sailors. as the liberty listed in the choppy seas, its deck aflame, crew members dropped life rafts into the water and prepared to scuttle the ship. given the number of wounded, this was going to be a dangerous operation. but it soon proved impossible, as the israeli attack boats strafed the rafts with machine gun fire. no body was going to get out alive that way. after more than two hours of unremitting assault, the israelis finally halted their attack. one of the torpedo boats approached the liberty. an officer asked in english over a bullhorn: "do you need any help?" the wounded commander of the liberty, lt. william mcgonagle, instructed the quartermaster to respond emphatically: "fuck you." the israeli boat turned and left. a soviet destroyer responded before the us navy, even though a us submarine, on a covert mission, was apparently in the area and had monitored the attack. the soviet ship reached the liberty six hours before the uss davis. the captain of the soviet ship offered his aid, but the liberty's commanding officer refused. finally, 16 hours after the attack two us destroyers reached the liberty. by that time, 34 us sailors were dead and 174 injured, many seriously. as the wounded were being evacuated, an officer with the office of naval intelligence instructed the men not to talk to the press about their ordeal. the following morning israel launched a surprise invasion of syria, breaching the new cease-fire agreement and seizing control of the golan heights. within three weeks, the navy put out a 700-page report, exonerating the israelis, claiming the attack had been accidental and that the israelis had pulled back as soon as they realized their mistake. defense secretary robert mcnamara suggested the whole affair should be forgotten. "these errors do occur," mcnamara concluded. *** in assault on the liberty, a first-hand account by james ennes jr., mcnamara's version of events is proven to be as big a sham as his concurrent lies about vietnam. ennes's book created a media storm when it was first published by random house in 1980, including (predictably) charges that ennes was a liar and an anti-semite. still, the book sold more than 40,000 copies, but was eventually allowed to go out of print. now ennes has published an updated version, which incorporates much new evidence that the israeli attack was deliberate and that the us government went to extraordinary lengths to disguise the truth. it's a story of israel aggression, pentagon incompetence, official lies, and a cover-up that persists to this day. the book gains much of its power from the immediacy of ennes's first-hand account of the attack and the lies that followed. now, 35 years later, ennes warns that the bloodbath on board the liberty and its aftermath should serve as a tragic cautionary tale about the continuing ties between the us government and the government of israel. the attack on the liberty is the kind of book that makes your blood seethe. ennes skillfully documents the life of the average sailor on one of the more peculiar vessels in the us navy, with an attention for detail that reminds one of dana or o'brien. after all, the year was 1967 and most of the men on the liberty were certainly glad to be on a non-combat ship in the middle of the mediterranean, rather than in the gulf of tonkin or mekong delta. but this isn't two years before the mast. in fact, ennes's tour on the liberty last only a few short weeks. he had scarcely settled into a routine before his new ship was shattered before his eyes. ennes joined the liberty in may of 1967, as an electronics material officer. serving on a "spook ship", as the liberty was known to navy wives, was supposed to be a sure path to career enhancement. the liberty's normal routine was to ply the african coast, tuning in its eavesdropping equipment on the electronic traffic in the region. the liberty had barely reached africa when it received a flash message from the joint chiefs of staff to sail from the ivory coast to the mediterranean, where it was to re-deploy off the coast of the sinai to monitor the israeli attack on egypt and the allied arab nations. as the war intensified, the liberty sent a request to the fleet headquarters requesting an escort. requesrt denied, by admiral william martin. the liberty moved alone to a position in international waters about 13 miles from the shore at el arish, then under furious siege by the idf. on june 6, the joint chiefs sent admiral mccain, father of the senator from arizona, an urgent message instructing him to move the liberty out of the war zone to a position at least 100 miles off the gaza coast. mccain never forwarded the message to the ship. a little after seven in the morning on june 8, ennes entered the bridge of the liberty to take the morning watch. ennes was told that an hour earlier a "flying boxcar" (later identified as a twin-engine nord 2501 noratlas) had flown over the ship at a low level. ennes says he noticed that the ship's american flag had become stained with soot and ordered a new flag run up the mast. the morning was clear and calm, with a light breeze. at 9 am, ennes spotted another reconnaissance plane, which circled the liberty. an hour later two israeli fighter jets buzzed the ship. over the next four hours, israeli planes flew over the liberty five more times. when the first fighter jet struck, a little before two in the afternoon, ennes was scanning the skies from the starboard side of the bridge, binoculars in his hands. a rocket hit the ship just below where ennes was standing, the fragments shredded the men closest to him. after the explosion, ennes noticed that he was the only man left standing. but he also had been hit by more than 20 shards of shrapnel and the force of the blast had shattered his left leg. as he crawled into the pilothouse, a second fighter jet streaked above them and unleashed its payload on the hobbled liberty. at that point, ennes says the crew of the liberty had no idea who was attacking them or why. for a few moments, they suspected it might be the soviets, after an officer mistakenly identified the fighters as mig-15s. they knew that the egyptian air force already had been decimated by the israelis. the idea that the israelis might be attacking them didn't occur to them until one of the crew spotted a star of david on the wing of one of the french-built mystere jets. ennes was finally taken below deck to a makeshift dressing station, with other wounded men. it was hardly a safe harbor. as ennes worried that his fractured leg might slice through his femoral artery leaving him to bleed to death, the liberty was pummeled by rockets, machine-gun fire and an italian-made torpedo packed with 1,000-pounds of explosive. after the attack ended, ennes was approached by his friend pat o'malley, a junior officer, who had just sent a list of killed and wounded to the bureau of naval personnel. he got an immediate message back. "they said, 'wounded in what action? killed in what action?'," o'malley told ennes. "they said it wasn't an 'action,' it was an accident. i'd like for them to come out here and see the difference between an action and an accident. stupid bastards." the cover-up had begun. *** the pentagon lied to the public about the attack on the liberty from the very beginning. in a decision personally approved by the loathsome mcnamara, the pentagon denied to the press that the liberty was an intelligence ship, referring to it instead as a technical research ship, as if it were little more than a military version of jacques cousteau's calypso. the military press corps on the uss america, where most of the wounded sailors had been taken, were placed under extreme restrictions. all of the stories filed from the carrier were first routed through the pentagon for security clearance, objectionable material was removed with barely a bleat of protest from the reporters or their publications. predictably, israel's first response was to blame the victim, a tactic that has served them so well in the palestinian situation. first, the idf alleged that it had asked the state department and the pentagon to identify any us ships in the area and was told that there were none. then the israeli government charged that the liberty failed to fly its flag and didn't respond to calls for it to identify itself. the israelis contended that they assumed the liberty was an egyptian supply ship called el quseir which, even though it was a rusting transport ship then docked in alexandria, the idf claimed was suspected of shelling israeli troops from the sea. under these circumstances, the israelis said they were justified in opening fire on the liberty. the israelis said that they halted the attack almost immediately, when they realized their mistake. "the liberty contributed decisively toward its identification as an enemy ship," the idf report concluded. this was entirely false, since the israelis had identified the liberty at least six hours prior to the attack on the ship. even though the pentagon knew better, it gave credence to the israeli account by saying that perhaps the liberty's flag had lain limp on the flagpole in a windless sea. the pentagon also suggested that the attack might have lasted less than 20 minutes. after the initial battery of misinformation, the pentagon imposed a news blackout on the liberty disaster until after the completion of a court of inquiry investigation. the inquiry was headed by rear admiral isaac c. kidd. kidd didn't have a free hand. he'd been instructed by vice-admiral mccain to limit the damage to the pentagon and to protect the reputation of israel. kidd interviewed the crew on june 14 and 15. the questioning was extremely circumscribed. according to ennes, the investigators "asked nothing that might be embarrassing to israel and testimony that tended to embarrass israel was covered with a 'top secret' label, if it was accepted at all." ennes notes that even testimony by the liberty's communications officers about the jamming of the ship's radios was classified as "top secret". the reason? it proved that israel knew it was attacking an american ship. "here was strong evidence that the attack was planned in advance and that our ship's identity was known to the attackers (for it its practically impossible to jam the radio of a stranger), but this information was hushed up and no conclusions were drawn from it," ennes writes. similarly, the court of inquiry deep-sixed testimony and affidavits regarding the flag. ennes, remember, had ordered a crisp new one deployed early on the morning of the attack. the investigators buried intercepts of conversations between idf pilots identifying the ship as flying an american flag. it also refused to accept evidence about the idf's use of napalm during the attacks and choose not to hear testimony regarding the duration of the attacks and the fact that the us navy failed to send planes to defend the ship. "no one came to help us," said dr. richard f. kiepfer, the liberty's physician. "we were promised help, but no help came. the russians arrived before our own ships did. we asked for an escort before we ever came to the war zone and we were turned down." none of this made its way into the 700-page court of inquiry report, which was completed within a couple of weeks and sent to admiral mccain in london for review. mccain approved the report over the objections of captain merlin staring, the navy legal officer assigned to the inquiry, who found the report to be flawed, incomplete and contrary to the evidence. staring sent a letter to the judge advocate general of the navy disavowing the report. the jag seemed to take staring's objections to heart. he prepared a summary for the chief of naval operations that almost completely ignored the kidd/mccain report. instead, it concluded: "that the liberty was easily recognizable as an american naval vessel; that its flag was fully deployed and flying in a moderate breeze; that israeli planes made at least eight reconnaissance flights at close range; the ship came under a prolonged attack from israeli fighter jets and torpedo boats." this succinct and largely accurate report was stamped top secret by navy brass and stayed locked up for many years. but it was seen by many in the pentagon and some in the oval office. but there was enough grumbling about the way the liberty incident had been handled that lbj summoned that old washington fixer clark clifford to do damage control. it didn't take clifford long to come up with the official line: the israelis simply had made a tragic mistake. it turns out that admiral kidd and captain ward boston, the two investigating officers who prepared the original report for admiral mccain, both believed that the israeli attack was intentional and sustained. in other words, the idf knew that they were striking an american spy ship and they wanted to sink it and kill as many sailors as possible. why then did the navy investigators produce a sham report that concluded it was an accident? twenty-five years later we've finally found out. in june of 2002, captain boston told the navy times: "officers follow orders." it gets worse. there's plenty of evidence that us intelligence agencies learned on june 7 that israel intended to attack the liberty on the following day and that the strike had been personally ordered by moshe dayan. as the attacks were going on, conversations between israeli pilots were overheard by us air force officers in an ec121 surveillance plane overhead. the spy plane was spotted by israeli jets, which were given orders to shoot it down. the american plane narrowly avoided the idf missiles. initial reports on the incident prepared by the cia, office of naval intelligence and the national security agency all reached similar conclusions. a particularly damning report compiled by a cia informant suggests that israeli defense minister moshe dayan personally ordered the attack and wanted it to proceed until the liberty was sunk and all on board killed. a heavily redacted version of the report was released in 1977. it reads in part: "[the source] said that dayan personally ordered the attack on the ship and that one of his generals adamantly opposed the action and said, 'this is pure murder.' one of the admirals who was present also disapproved of the action, and it was he who ordered it stopped and not dayan." this amazing document generated little attention from the press and dayan was never publicly questioned about his role in the attack. the analyses by the intelligence agencies are collected in a 1967 investigation by the defense subcommittee on appropriations. two and half decades later that report remains classified. why? a former committee staffer said: "so as not to embarrass israel." more proof has recently come to light from the israeli side. a few years after attack on the liberty was originally published, ennes got a call from evan toni, an israeli pilot. toni told ennes that he had just read his book and wanted to tell him his story. toni said that he was the pilot in the first israeli mirage fighter to reach the liberty. he immediately recognized the ship to be a us navy vessel. he radioed israeli air command with this information and asked for instructions. toni said he was ordered to "attack". he refused and flew back to the air base at ashdod. when he arrived he was summarily arrested for disobeying orders. *** how tightly does the israeli lobby control the hill? for the first time in history, an attack on an america ship was not subjected to a public investigation by congress. in 1980, adlai stevenson and barry goldwater planned to open a senate hearing into the liberty affair. then jimmy carter intervened by brokering a deal with menachem begin, where israel agreed to pony up $6 million to pay for damages to the ship. a state department press release announcing the payment said, "the book is now closed on the uss liberty." it certainly was the last chapter for adlai stevenson. he ran for governor of illinois the following year, where his less than perfect record on israel, and his unsettling questions about the liberty affair, became an issue in the campaign. big money flowed into the coffers of his republican opponent, big jim thompson, and stevenson went down to a narrow defeat. but the book wasn't closed for the sailors either, of course. after a newsweek story exposed the gist of what really happened on that day in the mediterranean, an enraged admiral mccain placed all the sailors under a gag order. when one sailor told an officer that he was having problems living with the cover-up, he was told: "forget about it, that's an order." the navy went to bizarre lengths to keep the crew of the liberty from telling what they knew. when gag orders didn't work, they threatened sanctions. ennes tells of the confinement and interrogation of two liberty sailors that sounds like something straight from the cia's mk-ultra program. "in an incredible abuse of authority, military officers held two young liberty sailors against their will in a locked and heavily guarded psychiatric ward of the base hospital," ennes writes. "for days these men were drugged and questioned about their recollections of the attack by a 'therapist' who admitted to being untrained in either psychiatry or psychology. at one point, they avoided electroshock only by bolting from the room and demanding to see the commanding officer." since coming home, the veterans who have tried to tell of their ordeal have been harassed relentlessly. they've been branded as drunks, bigots, liars and frauds. often, it turns out, these slurs have been leaked by the pentagon. and, oh yeah, they've also been painted as anti-semites. in a recent column, charley reese describes just how mean-spirited and petty this campaign became. "when a small town in wisconsin decided to name its library in honor of the uss liberty crewmen, a campaign claiming it was anti-semitic was launched," writes reese. "and when the town went ahead, the u.s. government ordered no navy personnel to attend, and sent no messages. this little library was the first, and at the time the only, memorial to the men who died on the liberty." *** so why then did the israelis attack the liberty? a few days before the six days war, israel's foreign minister abba eban visited washington to inform lbj about the forthcoming invasion. johnson cautioned eban that the us could not support such an attack. it's possible, then, that the idf assumed that the liberty was spying on the israeli war plans. possible, but not likely. despite the official denials, as andrew and leslie cockburn demonstrate in dangerous liaison, at the time of the six days war the us and israel had developed a warm covert relationship. so closely were the two sides working that us intelligence aid certainly helped secure israel's swift victory. in fact, it's possible that the liberty had been sent to the region to spy for the idf. a somewhat more likely scenario holds that moshe dayan wanted to keep the lid on israel's plan to breach the new cease-fire and invade into syria to seize the golan. it has also been suggested that dayan ordered the attack on the liberty with the intent of pinning the blame on the egyptians and thus swinging public and political opinion in the united states solidly behind the israelis. of course, for this plan to work, the liberty had to be destroyed and its crew killed. there's another factor. the liberty was positioned just off the coast from the town of el arish. in fact, ennes and others had used the town's mosque tower to fix the location of the ship along the otherwise featureless desert shoreline. the idf had seized el arish and had used the airport there as a prisoner of war camp. on the very day the liberty was attacked, the idf was in the process of executing as many as 1,000 palestinian and egyptian pows, a war crime that they surely wanted to conceal from prying eyes. according to gabriel bron, now an israeli reporter, who witnessed part of the massacre as a soldier: "the egyptian prisoners of war were ordered to dig pits and then army police shot them to death." the bigger question is why the us government would participate so enthusiastically in the cover-up of a war crime against its own sailors. well, the pentagon has never been slow to hide its own incompetence. and there's plenty of that in the liberty affair: bungled communications, refusal to provide an escort, situating the defenseless liberty too close to a raging battle, the inability to intervene in the attack and the inexcusably long time it took to reach the battered ship and its wounded. that's par for the course. but something else was going on that would only come to light later. through most of the 1960s, the us congress had imposed a ban on the sale of arms to both israel and jordan. but at the time of the liberty attack, the pentagon (and its allies in the white house and on the hill) was seeking to have this proscription overturned. the top brass certainly knew that any evidence of a deliberate attack on a us navy ship by the idf would scuttle their plans. so they hushed it up. in january 1968, the arms embargo on israel was lifted and the sale of american weapons began to flow. by 1971, israel was buying $600 million of american-made weapons a year. two years later the purchases topped $3 billion. almost overnight, israel had become the largest buyer of us-made arms and aircraft. perversely, then, the idf's strike on the liberty served to weld the us and israel together, in a kind of political and military embrace. now, every time the idf attacks defenseless villages in gaza and the west bank with f-16s and apache helicopters, the palestinians quite rightly see the bloody assaults as a joint operation, with the pentagon as a hidden partner. thus, does the legacy of liberty live on, one raid after another. this is essay appears in the politics of anti-semitism edited by alexander cockburn and jeffrey st. clair. jeffrey st. clair is the author of been brown so long it looked like green to me: the politics of nature and grand theft pentagon. his newest book is end times: the death of the fourth estate, co-written with alexander cockburn. he can be reached at: sitka@comcast.net   now available! the gang's all here: judy miller, bob woodward, jeffrey goldberg, rupert murdoch, bill o'reilly...end times leaves no reputation unstained! buy end times now! now available from counterpunch books! saul landau's bush and botox world with a foreword by gore vidal click here to order!   "the case against israel" michael neumann's devastating rebuttal of alan dershowitz what's inside grand theft pentagon: tales of greed and profiteering in the war on terror by jeffrey st. clair       the occupation by patrick cockburn humanitarian imperialism by jean bricmont   city beautiful by tennessee reed   bruce springsteen on tour by dave marsh   the book on 9/11 the white house denounced as "absolute garbage"        

Acceuil

suivante

jeffrey st. clair: israel's attack on the uss liberty, revisited  york  Emergency targets Pakistani activists - Yahoo! News  re: Voice Actors - Neoseeker Forums  dOc Power Search Results  Movies tagged with the "hostage" keyword free movie, mp3 ...  INFILM.DE - das Kurzfilmkino  Papillon Coffee Acoustic Concert Series, Lafayette, Ca  N.I.K.E.-1 BASKETBALL TEAM: My Site News  GreenCine Daily: October 2005 Archives  Conservative Blog Therapy: Israeli video: <em>we will send you ...  Table of contents : Nature  Untitled  jerusalem is the place to be: May 2006  MySpace.com - harvey - 101 - Male - - www.myspace.com/yourpalharvey  Nassau fall sports -- Newsday.com  FOOT PLUS + Football.fr - mars 2007 - TOUTES LES VIDEOS ET LES ...  Jerome Bourdon - Some Sense of Time: Remembering Television ...  BIOONE Online Journals - Invited Paper: Chemicals from nature for ...  Montreal Film Journal  IQI Publications  BroadwayStars  Gerard Depardieu - news, photos, reviews, filmography, rent DVDs ...  The lesson in human rights education applicable to American ...  MDST 440/ENSP 481: Film Theory Professor Nitin Govil ( govil ...  Le Quotidien du Cinéma / index général des critiques de films (1 ...  Rosemary’s Thoughts  Gérard Depardieu - Wikipédia  Euro 2008 qual. - November 17 Squads - Yahoo! Eurosport UK  knight DVD Movies Library,Download in DVD, DivX, iPod quality ...  List of fictional planets by medium - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia   Video merkezi Yerlitube.com Bizim video portalımız Video ...  Los Angeles Galaxy: News: Article  JCC Gala 2003: Auction List: Silent Auction G-N  Le Blog Télévision  thebushtheatre  Gérard Depardieu - CF  Bhutto: I will not negotiate with Musharaff the Daily Mail  Townhall.com::Blog  CBU School of Sciences Charity Basketball Game 2000 -- Page 2  HFPA - Awards Search  Canterbury Film Society :: Schedule from 1988  New Materials in the San Elijo Campus Library —July 2007  Untitled Document  NISTNCSTAR1CollapseofTowers  FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE  The Demilitarized Zone » Books  iina.biz - ニュース  Prince George's Area Science Fair - April 6, 2003  Houston Dynamo: News: Article  XOOPS Russia  Past Productions : About the Powerhouse  Writers Strike Sends Shows Into Reruns - Examiner.com  Woodbine Entertainment Group Entries and Results  The National and the Popular in Israeli Cinema  Bibliotique at antiqbook.com  Amazon.co.uk: £50 - £100 - English / World Cinema: DVD  IBPC: Poetry and Poets in Rags  Saturday, September 02, 2006  futodoki tumblr: Archive  NISTNCSTAR1CollapseofTowers