bw online | october 6, 2003 | web searches: the fix is in

bw online | october 6, 2003 | web searches: the fix is in register sign in current issue risk-free issues subscribe now home investing companies technology autos innovation small biz b-schools managing asia europe magazine    get four free issues register subscribe to bw customer service full table of contents cover story up front editor's memo readers report corrections & clarifications books technology & you economic viewpoint economic trends industry insider business outlook news: analysis & commentary in biz this week washington outlook asian business european business international outlook science & technology developments to watch information technology media sports biz marketing government finance industrial management legal affairs people personal business footnotes the barker portfolio inside wall street figures of the week editorials international editions international -- readers report international -- finance international -- int'l figures of the week premium content mba insider bw magazine get four free issues register subscribe customer service online features book reviews bw video columnists interactive gallery newsletters past covers philanthropy podcasts special reports blogs auto beat bangalore tigers blogspotting brand new day byte of the apple economics unbound eye on asia fine on media green biz hot property investing insights management iq next: innovation nussbaumondesign tech beat working parents technology j.d. power ratings product reviews tech stats wildstrom: tech maven autos home page auto reviews classic cars car care & safety hybrids innovation & design home page architecture brand equity auto design game room smallbiz smart answers success stories today's tip investing investing: europe annual reports bw 50 s&p picks & pans stock screeners free s&p stock report scoreboards hot growth 100 mutual funds info tech 100 s&p 500 b-schools undergrad programs mba blogs mba profiles mba rankings who's hiring grads bw extras bw digital bw mobile bw online alerts dashboard widgets podcasts rss feeds reprints/ permissions conferences research services october 6, 2003     story tools printer-friendly version e-mail this story graphic: what's in your search results? information technology web searches: the fix is in commentary: wireless: answer the call information technology web searches: the fix is in how much exposure can you buy? plenty, concludes a businessweek probe they're called spiders. scores of these digital robots crawl through cyberspace, scouring the billions of pages in the world wide web. they catalog all the words in the pages, how many times they're viewed, and which other pages they link to. these spiders power the fast-growing search industry, led by google, yahoo! (yhoo ) and microsoft's msn. this is quickly becoming humanity's favorite tool for finding out just about anything, with 550 million internet searches performed worldwide each day. type in a couple words, say "sleeping" and "bag," and the engine, fueled by its spiders and scientific algorithms, promptly provide a list of web sites, starting with the most relevant. right? not so fast. in the last year, a host of search engines, including msn and lycos (trly ), have sprinkled growing numbers of paid corporate web pages into the search results and accepting money each time one of these so-called paid-inclusion links is clicked. this practice is a booming business, one expected to double this year, to $200 million, and to reach $600 million by 2007, says u.s. bancorp piper jaffray (usb ). but unlike the clearly marked advertised links that show up next to search results, these paid inclusions are virtually invisible to average web surfers. only specialists prepared to decipher web addresses can begin to distinguish between the paid and unpaid pages. "these are not objective oracles of information," says beau brendler, director of consumer webwatch, a project of consumers union. controversy over paid inclusion is driving a wedge through the search industry. at the heart of the issue is whether the industry's content will be swayed by advertisers. google, the leading search engine, steers clear of paid inclusions, saying that they undermine confidence in the objectivity of search results. instead, google relies entirely upon its technology for the search, and features paid ads only in clearly marked boxes near the search results. aol uses google technology and follows the same line. but others, including yahoo, say that paid inclusion can provide users with better information. and they maintain that their search results are still displayed in order of relevance. that means that paid ads get no preferential treatment. "all listings are run through an algorithm that is blind to their source," says tony mamone, sales vice-president at looksmart (look ) ltd., which feeds paid-inclusion results to portals like msn. ticket to the top yet an investigation by businessweek, based on more than 30 interviews and analysis of dozens of internet searches, suggests that paying customers frequently fare better. indeed, out of 20 advertisers and online marketing pros interviewed by businessweek, 10 had experienced firsthand a boost in search-engine rankings when they signed up for paid inclusion. says james taylor, ceo of aicompany.com, a search-marketing company, "paid inclusion dilutes the accuracy and relevance of a search engine." dennis swanson learned the hard way. earlier this year, the chief executive of lamps plus inc., couldn't understand why his e-commerce offerings for light fixtures turned up so prominently in google but were nearly out of sight on msn. so he paid to have his site included with looksmart, which feeds search results to msn and shares with msn revenues it gets from advertisers. almost instantly, lamps plus pages soared to near the top of msn's search results, and microsoft's portal became swanson's biggest traffic driver. when he temporarily stopped his looksmart deal, msn's traffic spigot shut off. "if we don't have a deal with looksmart, we don't show up in msn's results," he says. msn, while declining to comment on this case, says it is currently reevaluating its entire internet search offering, including paid-inclusion listings, to put forth the most relevant results. hits and misses what gives? for starters, the paid-inclusion pages are easily engineered for high placement. when submitting paid-inclusion data, companies typically fill out a spreadsheet with information on product details, along with the search words and phrases for which they'd like to appear. the result is a rich stream of data targeted precisely to what the search engine will deem relevant. consequently, their ratings are primed to soar. anecdotal examples aren't tough to turn up. plug in "green sleeping bag" to hotbot.com and the first six results, in a recent search, featured paid-inclusion listings from inktomi, which is now owned by yahoo. some weren't even for sleeping bags. the fifth listing took users to a paid-inclusion product page for a white canvas bag. meanwhile, numerous pure results displayed lower were highly relevant product pages for green sleeping bags. a yahoo spokesperson responds that there are just as many examples of paid-inclusion listings improving search results. despite criticisms, the paid-inclusion business addresses some very real needs. one biggie is the sheer number of web pages tucked away in corporate databases, where search-engine spiders have a difficult time navigating. by letting, say, staples.com pipe its data directly to a search engine, a user seeking "inkjet cartridges" could get a fresh listing from staples.com that might not otherwise show up. "we use [paid inclusion] only if it's improving the relevance of our results," says tim cadogan, yahoo's vice-president for search. still, the growth of paid inclusion could tilt the search business toward deep-pocketed companies. for instance, travel sites that want to be in looksmart's paid-inclusion program have to pay the company a flat rate of 30 cents for each click, according to the company's web site. jumbo chains like marriott international (mar ) inc. or hilton hotels (hlt ) corp. are certainly better equipped to cover such costs than, say, a bed-and-breakfast. just ask rob spooner. the 56-year-old runs a travel site called online highways with informational pages about various small towns throughout the u.s. inktomi, a search engine that now belongs to yahoo, contacted him late last year about becoming a paid-inclusion participant. the proposal: spooner would pay 10 cents for every visitor inktomi passed along. spooner did the math, figured he would lose money on anything more than 3 cents a click, and declined the offer. then things went downhill. spooner's web pages soon plunged in inktomi's search rankings and disappeared from key sites like msn, where inktomi feeds its listings. after he demanded to know what happened, spooner learned from inktomi that his site contained editorial flaws that hurt his ranking. and he would have to become a paid-inclusion customer to learn what these flaws were. all this, while his pages remained well ranked on google. "i lost a quarter of my traffic," says spooner. yahoo declined to comment on this incident. however, it and other search engines offering paid inclusion say it serves the customers' interest. says tom wilde, general manager of search services at terra lycos: "if you deliver a poor user experience, people leave, and they leave rapidly." and why not label the sponsored links? many search companies and advertisers fret that marking them would scare the public away from relevant sites. says glenn mclaren, e-commerce manager at friedrich air conditioning: "part of what makes it attractive is that it doesn't look like advertising." the trouble is, if paid inclusions are hidden, readers could grow to dismiss internet search as nothing but a pile of ads. by ben elgin in san mateo, calif.  bw mall  sponsored links trade the us dollar  get into forex trading - sign up for a free $50,000 practice account. protect your company vital information assets  50% of u.s. companies suffer from ineffective document management. learn how oce can help. richardson's online sales & service training  fast. easy. effective. improve the selling skills of your team with richardson’s on-demand elearning free sap case study for midsize companies  thousands of successful companies run sap to achieve business goals. download "success stories" now. virtual phone service for small business  virtual phone system answers, screens and routes calls to you automatically. as low as $9.95/month. buy a link now! get businessweek directly on your desktop with our rss feeds. add businessweek news to your web site with our headline feed. click to buy an e-print or reprint of a businessweek or businessweek online story or video. to subscribe online to businessweek magazine, please click here. learn more, go to the businessweekonline home page today's most popular stories ibm, cognos, and the end of best-of-breed the economy on the edge investing in 'fortress' stocks wimax suffers a setback is raising kids a fool's game? get free rss feed >>   market info djia 13307.09 +319.54 s&p 500 1481.05 +41.87 nasdaq 2673.65 +89.52 portfolio service update stock lookup enter name or ticker copyright 2003, by the mcgraw-hill companies inc. all rights reserved. terms of use | privacy policy media kit | special sections | marketplace | knowledge centers

Acceuil

suivante

bw online | october 6, 2003 | web searches: the fix is in  Fix-masseau (pierre) affiches 1928-83 - Edité par BIBLIOTHEQUE ...  OpenSUSE releases package manager fix  Fix Munin Exim Mail débit problème de la mise à jour graphique pas ...  Durg's Vegetation Fix - Forums ArmA-Fr.net  HTML FIX IT.COM: A site with free scripts, advanced scripts ...  Tarif sunbeam w-pci rack kit fix bay accessoires pour boîtier w ...  Fix You :: Coldplay :: paroles de chanson :: traduction ...  Click to activate and use this control - KB912812 Capitalhead.com  Aural Fix Communique Online  globeandmail.com: Ottawa to fix rural vote glitch  FBorFW.com is The Official Website of Lynn Johnston's comic strip ...  RipollP => cheville SPIT FIX 2 8x70/20  RipollP => Chevilles à expansion SPIT FIX 2 10x95 /35  [fix]liste de fix/optimisation :: Fire Soft Board  Hacker Dude-san's Page  NSX FIX Specification  Kids Are Waiting: Fix Foster Care Now  Fortis Assurances - Activ’ Optioun Fix et Flex  La roll roys des couches lavables. Easy fix blanche.  Offre d’emploi FIX Connectivity Analyst/Specialist (Java, C++ ...  Fix your Time Machine with the Flux Capacitor 9 to 5 Mac  Fix und Foxi - Wikipedia  for sale buy ski ski race-carve atomic sl11 test 2006 +fix 2006 ...  Ontwerpbureau Fix  Odyssey Adventure Racing - OARevents.com  Jeffrey Sachs: How I'd fix the World Bank - Jun. 26, 2007  Pinky swear: Tax writers tell IRS they'll fix AMT - Oct. 31, 2007  Fresh Fix! News Cinéma, Jeux video, Séries, Publicites, Clips ...  Azimer Audio 0.56 WIP 2 Fix - Emu Nova  skillsize*.international » Collection « Test it, fix it » - Oxford ...  Fix-St-Geneys Commerces & Services - Yahoo! Local France  Porte outil - REGO-FIX - DirectIndustry  The fix is in for pet control - USATODAY.com  cdm-iso-machine-fix - CDM  SubZero Fix pour PS Two :: Assentek  Informations de presse - Konrad Hornschuch AG - d-c-fix, dcfix, skai  PC News: Flagship to fix Hellgate - ComputerAndVideoGames.com  Café Fix - Kontaktladen mit medizinischer Ambulanz  CAMP - Ice Rider New Fix + Atb  Ljubljana - Fix le 03 Septembre 2007 - NC  Photo : fix-1-255.jpg - vietnam - www.developpementdurableasie.com  La Voix du Sud > Sports > Une 1re défaite pour le Fix Auto  Photojojo » Find Detail in Your Photos That You Thought Was Lost ...  Crampons pour bois Krall-Fix.  Fix You (Cover Tones fix you) (sonnerie.01net.com)  YUI Version 2.3.1: Bug-Fix Release » Yahoo! User Interface Blog  Fix those Aluminium Keyboard woes - The Unofficial Apple Weblog (TUAW)  skis atomic 130 fix look Article de sport Toulouse  The Wheel Fix  Hama LOT DE 5 SERRE-CABLES NOIR PEARL FIX comparer prix acheter ...  AB Soft propose Fix-It et SystemSuite de V-Com  ID'FIX : Education canine, formation, pension canine et Agility  Fix font issue in Safari for Windows - Grupenet  ID-FIX Groupe Rock  Rhodia : Rhodia rachete l’activite Mix & Fix Center de Quimica Dos ...  NASA delays spacewalk to fix broken solar wing: Scientific American  Procédure d’utilisation de la fonction Facing Fix SANS utilisation ...  Scan, Click & Fix : de l’analyse de vulnérabilités à la ...  CREDIT AGRICOLE SA : fix 25.03 > plein de GAGNANTS >  TOTAL : JEU du FIX MARDI 6 /11 / 2007