3 ways to fix citigroup
3 ways to fix citigroup
quotes:search:homestock researchdiscussion boardsquotesmy foolcapsnewsinvestingretirementpersonal financefool's schoolfeedbackhelpwelcome loginsign up
choose a broker
today's headlines
products & services
asia rising
caps beta
champion funds
discussion boards
fool credit card
global gains
hidden gems
income investor
inside value
million dollar portfolio
pay dirt
rule breakers
rule makers
rule your retirement
stock advisor
tmf green light
more...
investing
bonds
broker comparison
etfs
index funds
mutual funds
stock ideas
more...
personal finance
401(k)
calculators
credit reports
home buying/rates
insurance
iras
savings/cds
taxes
travel center
more...
site changes
rss headlines
sitemap/more topics
email subscriptions
media center
work at the fool
email
print
contact us
digg
delicious
rss
the most foolish
recommended
read
emailed
recent
most recommended
articles published in the last 7 days
the sky is falling
bernanke's plan to pick your pocket
marvel is a screaming buy
tomtom to garmin: oh, it's on, baby
just another quarter for berkshire
how to profit from this incredible fiasco
quit calling akamai expensive
3 stocks to buy in 2008
10 time bomb tickers
nothing scary about dryships' profits
most searched value investing articles
related tickers
caignyxshldusbwfc
citigroup, inc.
c
$35.90
+2.33
(+6.94%)
[4:00 pm]
caps rating:
2277 outperforms
498 underperforms
rate this stock
related articles about c
the millionaire in the next cubicle[11/13/2007 2:25:00 pm]
2 ways to value a company[11/13/2007 11:24:00 am]
the lesson from e*trade[11/12/2007 4:17:00 pm]
c rss feed
major indices
s&p 5001,481.05+2.91%
djia13,307.09+2.46%
rsl 2k789.15+2.88%
nasd2,673.65+3.46%
updated: 4:03:34 pm
sponsored by:
the motley poll
have you ever been a victim of identity theft?
yes: accounts were opened in my name
yes: charges were made to my credit card or bank account
no
sponsored by:
sponsored by
value investing
3 ways to fix citigroup
by emil lee
november 5, 2007
12
recommendations
it's been quite tantalizing to watch citigroup's (nyse: c) shares sink to five-year lows --Â buried underneath the horrible news headlines lies an unparalleled money-making machine. i'm no financial genius, but i believe there's a simple way to unleash citi's potential and send its shares skyrocketing.
act 1: capital restructurefirst off, citi needs to shore up the balance sheet, even if that means cutting the dividend or diluting current shareholders -- no short-term pain, no long-term gain. after all, a bank relies on its balance sheet to extend loans and pay depositors, so it's better to make sure the patient is fully rehabilitated before sending it back out into the business jungle.
thus, citi's management should place a couple of calls to the likes of warren buffett at berkshire hathaway (nyse: brk-a) (nyse: brk-b), eddie lampert at sears holding (nasdaq: shld), and saudi arabian prince alwaleed bin alsaud (a major shareholder) to raise somewhere in the neighborhood of $25 billion to $30 billion, the amount cibc analyst meredith whitney suggested citi needs to remain healthy.
sure, raising additional capital would dilute current shareholders by about 10%-15% (depending on the conversion premium), which is a slight negative, because current shareholders will thus own less of the company. however, i think a little dilution is a minor price to pay to fix the balance sheet and reposition citigroup for future success.
act 2: instill confidenceciti's problems are neither structural nor pervasive among its distinct collections of strong businesses. for example, the problems with structured investment vehicles (sivs) and collateralized debt obligation (cdo) credit quality do not hinder citi's ability to offer wealth management services at the smith barney division, or credit cards to consumer bankers. the problems are localized and fixable.
after raising that $25 billion, citi could amputate the tumor by effectively getting rid of its exposure to credit-sensitive securities. keep in mind, i am not suggesting that citi have a fire sale of its cdos and leveraged loans.
rather, armed with a $25 billion war chest, citi could resecuritize, hedge, and insure its troubled securities to get rid of the malignant credit tumor. this should help shunt exposure to its estimated $55 billion in remaining subprime exposure (for which citi estimates it may need to take an additional $8 billion to $10 billion loss), $80 billion in sivs (although it doesn't bear credit risk, it has some liquidity risk), and $57 billion in leveraged loan commitments as of the latest quarter.
in addition, the announcement of former treasury secretary robert rubin as interim chairman should provide a psychological boost to the credit markets. rubin's role will be to pick a new ceo, with possible candidates including john thain, current ceo of nyse euronext (nyse: nyx); robert willumstad, citi's former coo and current chairman of aig (nyse: aig); and vikram pandit, who heads up citi's alternative investment businesses. installing a ceo with a track record as a skilled operator, and more important, one with risk management skills, should help boost citi's stock.
act 3: break it up!citigroup's shares trade at a huge conglomerate discount. boutique investment banks like greenhill and lazard, wealth managers like raymond james, and diversified consumer banks like us bancorp (nyse: usb) and wells fargo (nyse: wfc) trade in the 20, 15, and 12 times trailing price earning multiples ranges.
citigroup, which boasts extremely competitive positions in most of its businesses, should trade near or at a slight discount to these multiples -- shares are currently trading at less than eight times 2008 earnings estimates. if citigroup simply split into consumer banking, capital markets, and wealth management divisions, it would almost certainly increase in value, become much more nimble, and remove layers of bureaucratic expenses.
the synergies of the financial supermarket model have never worked. sure, it makes sense for consumer banks to offer credit cards. but it doesn't make much sense to pair an investment bank and a consumer bank. jane or joe schmo won't walk into a bank, deposit $100, and then ask for merger and acquisition advice.
so there you have it. anyone who has ever read "you can be a stock market genius" can attest to the fact that spin-offs handily outperform the market once freed from an onerous and bureaucratic structure. it may be time for citi to regroup, spin off into separate businesses, and finally allow its shares to beat the market.
related foolishness:
and the world's scariest stock is ...
stop being greedy and you'll make more money
what you don't know about peter lynch
get the best of the fool delivered to your inbox every friday
your email:
berkshire hathaway is a stock advisor pick. nyse euronext is a rule breakers selection. us bancorp and berkshire hathaway are inside value recommendations. try any one of our investing services free for 30 days.
fool contributor emil lee is an analyst and a disciple of value investing. he doesn't own shares in any of the companies mentioned. emil appreciates your comments, concerns, and complaints. the motley fool has a disclosure policy.
email
print
feedback
digg
delicious
rss
compare brokers
td ameritrade
more info
sharebuilder
more info
power e*trade
more info
compare all
more info
fool disclosure
documentid: 539725, ~/articles/articlehandler.aspx, 11/13/2007 11:52:49 pm
home
about the motley fool
email subscriptions
newspaper column
work at the fool
contact us
advertise
fool disclosure
help
site map
rss headlines
fool friends:
yahoo finance, msn money, aol money
legal information ©1995-2007 the motley fool. all rights reserved.
219ms useq\eqweb06
Acceuil
suivante
3 ways to fix citigroup
CTV.ca Astronauts embark on risk spacewalk to fix sail Fix your mom's computer for mother's day - Joel on Software Welcome to Gia's Fix Fix the Future: What this site is all about. Actualité sur VJ FIX - Dates de concerts, albums, Mp3, vidéos ... how to mend it .com - Find out how to mend just about anything Baseball Glove Repair And Restore BW Online March 19, 2001 How to Fix America's Schools Windows MaxMTU Fix - HelpWithWindows.com THERMAL FIX - Thermal Fix 1 - Tube THERMAL FIX - Thermal Fix 2 - Tube SPLANN BLITZ FIX (l'éponge miracle, Eco logis, Eco respect ... A fix for Suckerfish dropdowns in IE 7 How to Fix Shows Like 'Lost' -- New York Magazine Mike Volodarsky's ServerSide : Fix problems with Visual Studio F5 ... Glisshop :: Conseils ski - Montage fix FairVote The Center for Voting & Democracy ONLamp.com -- How to Decide What Bugs to Fix When, Part 1 /IE7/ Google Tries to Fix Broken Links How To Fix Overexposed Images PhotoshopSupport.com Konrad Hornschuch AG - d-c-fix, dcfix, skai Klebefolien ... HYJEK AND FIX, INC. Daily Herald Officials promise quick fix to state's finance woes Achat et location Fix Saint Geneys fix Sommier LATTOFLEX LT25 Fix 2 pers. 140x190 Ferme / La Compagnie du ... George Fix Ablöse fix: Bewkes folgt Parson als Time-Warner-Chef The Draw System [adult swim] Fix Schedule Resize or Convert Images online Active Content Developer Center LUX ELEMENTS®- FIX - Jeux de fixation MIST & FIX - Brume Fixatrice de Maquillage - Fixateur de ... Alpinisme -- Petites annonces - Re: vends chaussures neuves et fix ... Vichy Thermal Fix Yeux - 15 ml Polident Languettes Fix Confort - 40 languettes Orna Cohen-Fix, Ph.D. : Faculty : NIDDK Laboratories Inventgeek.com - LCD Backlight Fix - Overview MG WinSock XP Fix 1.2 Chez Fix Garbage - Fix Me Now – Musique sur Last.fm Technology News: Space: ISS Astronaut to Perform Perilous ... M700 Glofiish GPS SiRF III instant fix intégré Smartphone ETEN Django security fix released OE-QuoteFix SPACE.com -- NASA Reveals Plan to Fix Solar Wing Téléchargement NOD32.FiX.v2.1-nsane.exe Trev’s Travels » Blog » Word Fix Plugin [s1] Episode 13 - The Fix (Le Remède) This Global Warming Fix Stinks Session Fix :: Firefox Add-ons How to Change the World: The Entrepreneur's New Year's Resolution ... Fix Brothers Fruit Farm REGO-FIX® - Swiss Precision Tools - collets, toolholders, nuts ... Eric's Archived Thoughts: Framework Fix Dent Fix Equipment IEFix Utility - Description Recette Cocktail Whisky Fix ¤ 1001 Cocktails