solar shield could be quick fix for global warming - earth - 05 june 2007 - new scientist environment
solar shield could be quick fix for global warming - earth - 05 june 2007 - new scientist environment
new scientist|space|technology|environment|new scientist jobs|subscribe to new scientist
solar shield could be quick fix for global warming
15:35 05 june 2007
newscientist.com news service
catherine brahic
printsendfeeds
with a solar shield, temperatures would be roughly the same as in 1900 (c), but precipitation would drop (d). without the shield, temperatures would rise dramatically (a), and precipitation would increase in some regions and drop in others (b) (image: pnas/caldeira/matthews)enlarge
tools
advertisement
a solar shield that reflects some of the sun's radiation back into space would cool the climate within a decade and could be a quick-fix solution to climate change, researchers say.
because of their rapid effect, however, they should be deployed only as a last resort when "dangerous" climate change is imminent, they warn.
solar shields are not a new idea - such "geoengineering" schemes to artificially cool the earth's climate are receiving growing interest, and include proposals to inject reflective aerosols into the stratosphere, deploying space-based solar reflectors and large-scale cloud seeding.
the shields are inspired by the cooling effects of large volcanic eruptions that blast sulphate particles into the stratosphere. there, the particles reflect part of the sun's radiation back into space, reducing the amount of heat that reaches the atmosphere, and so dampening the greenhouse effect.
the 1991 eruption of mount pinatubo in the philippines cooled earth by a few tenths of a degree for several years.
quick-acting
ken caldeira at the carnegie institution of washington, in california, us, and damon matthews at concordia university, canada, used computer models to simulate the effects that a solar shield would have on the earth's climate if greenhouse gas emissions continued to rise along a "business as usual" scenario.
"we have been trying to pinpoint the one really bad thing that argues against geoengineering the climate," says caldeira. "but it is really hard to find."
his computer models simulated a gradually deployed shield that would compensate for the greenhouse effect of rising carbon dioxide concentrations. by the time co2 levels are double those of pre-industrial times - predicted to be at the end of the 21st century - the shield would need to block 8% of the sun's radiation.
the researchers found that a sulphur shield could act very quickly, lowering temperatures to around early 20th-century levels within a decade of being deployed.
"the trouble is, the decadal timescale works both ways," says caldeira. a sulphate shield would need to be continuously replenished, and the models show that failing to do so would mean the earth's climate would suddenly be hit with the full warming effect of the co2 that has accumulated in the meantime.
"so if you have the shield up there and it fails - or, for example, the republicans put up a shield and then the democrats come in to power and turn it down - then you effectively compress into a decade or two the warming that would have happened while the shield was up," caldeira explains.
poorly understood
a solar shield would not necessarily stunt plant growth. in fact, there is some evidence that plants grew more vigorously after mt pinatubo erupted because the sulphate particles increased the amount of diffuse light and boosted growth in shaded areas. but if a shield was suddenly removed, a portion of the co2 stored in plants would be suddenly released as the plants respire faster in warmer temperatures.
"personally, as a citizen not a scientist, i don't like geo-engineering because of the high environmental risk," caldeira told new scientist. "it's toying with poorly understood complex systems."
and the ease with which they could work is also risky, he says: "these schemes are almost too cheap and easy. just one fire hose spraying sulphur dioxide into the atmosphere would do the job for a century. that would cost about $100 million - nothing in comparison to the hundreds of billions it would take to transform our energy supply."
but he also believes it is time to consider solar shields seriously. on 1 june, james hansen, head of nasa's institute for space studies in the us, published a paper stating that earths' climate system has reached a tipping point (atmospheric chemistry and physics, vol 7, p 2287).
lesser of two evils?
hansen's study suggests that only moderate additional warming is likely to trigger the disintegration of the west antarctic and arctic ice sheets - events which would be near-impossible to reverse.
"if this is the case, then i am not clear on what the 'greenest' path is," says caldeira. "is it better to let the greenland ice sheet collapse and let the polar bears drown their way to extinction, or to spray some sulphur particles in the stratosphere?"
he says that if forced to consider deploying a solar shield, "we would need to be confident that we would not be creating bigger problems than we are solving. therefore, it is important both to understand the mess we are in today - how close are we to making irreversible changes, how fast can we alter our energy system - and to understand what might happen should we try to avoid some of the worst outcomes by engineering our climate".
caldeira and matthews also found that a solar shield would not correct abnormalities in rainfall. most notably, the tropics would receive less rain than in the absence of the greenhouse effect, as predicted by climate change models.
journal references: proceedings of the national academy of sciences (doi: 10.1073/pnas.0700419104)
climate change - want to know more about global warming: the science, impacts and political debate? visit our continually updated special report.
add a comment
comment subject
comment
no html except lower case italic tags or lower case bold tags, please: <i> or <b>
your name
your email
we need your email in case we need to contact you about the comment. we will not use it for any other purpose.
there are 2 comments on 1 page
view thread >>
solar shield
by valerie bensen
tue aug 07 07:00:44 bst 2007
with all the recent talk going on regarding "chem trails", it seems very coincidental that the science community is exploring the possible use of solar shields to be sent into our atmosphere for the answer to global warming. sounds to me like it's already being tried out which would explain perfectly what these so called mystery "chem trails" are all about! ya think?
report | reply
solar shield
by benji eagle
mon sep 10 16:49:23 bst 2007
all of that aint true the world is getting hot
report | reply
view thread >>
there are 2 comments on 1 page
all comments should respect the new scientist house rules. if you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "report" link in that comment to report it to us.
if you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.
related articles
sunblock
pumping iron in the pacific
web links
far-out schemes to stop climate change, new scientist blog
ken caldeira, carnegie institution of washington
geo-engineering, wikipedia
abstract, proceedings of the national academy of sciences
atmospheric chemistry and physics
printsendfeeds
for exclusive news and expert analysis every week subscribe to new scientist print edition
for what's in new scientist magazine this week see contents
search all stories
contact us about this story
sign up for our free newsletter
search
›search tips
home
stories
blog
video
special reports
subscribe
search
feeds
print edition
›current issue
›archive
›full access
›uk bird flu outbreak confirmed as h5n1
›climate change is delaying spring in some areas
›astronomers defend asteroid warning mix-up
›synchronised shaking connects gadgets securely
›hydrogen brewing gets an electrical boost
›invention: heart-powered pacemaker
›astronomers defend asteroid warning mix-up
›new evidence for extragalactic life-forming matter
›antique fridge could keep venus rover cool
latest news
›climate change is delaying spring in some areas
›hydrogen brewing gets an electrical boost
›more bear species threatened with extinction
›tiger numbers halved by new census
›are men to blame for global warming?
more stories
subscribe |
contact us |
faq / help |
advertise |
disclaimer |
terms and conditions |
cookies |
privacy policy |
open source |
site map
about newscientist.com |
about new scientist magazine |
publisher blog
© copyright reed business information ltd.
Acceuil
suivante
solar shield could be quick fix for global warming - earth - 05 june 2007 - new scientist environment Free Registry Fix 3.9 for Windows Video Coldplay - Fix You - coldplay, fix, you, clip ... FIX: Update to enable DirectX Video Acceleration (DXVA) of Windows ... You receive an access violation error and the system may appear to ... GRC CIH Virus Recovery How to Fix CGI - majordojo serious fix 4.1 Why Blog Post Frequency Does Not Matter Anymore Marketing Profs ... FOSSwire » Fix a Frozen System with the Magic SysRq Keys Windows Vista Team Blog : Partners helping fix Vista Software ... Objet Publicitaire : Magnet Magic fix - ALB01.com Indonesia's three divas fix the nation's finances International ... Rob Galbraith DPI: EOS-1D Mark III sub-mirror fix announced in USA ... KompoZer - Easy web authoring Mr. Fix It (2006) XML.com: Using XSLT to Fix Swing [Profil de fix] OverBlog - Le blog des blogs Fix Your Money Screw-Ups - Kiplinger.com frontline: the wall street fix PBS Portail Internet de la Haute Autorité de santé - H-FIX PDS Your Freebie Fix - All the latest Freebies, Coupons and Online Deals はてなブックマーク - FIX Bug Fix Weekend finished :: pnCommunity :: Support at your fingertips Windows Mobile 5.0 Fix Site - Home Tena Fix - Incontinence Google to fix blog noise problem The Register BBC/OU Open2.net - Can Gerry Robinson Fix The NHS? Two charged with hacking PeopleSoft to fix grades - Network World Bike Shop Frederick, Maryland Bike Repairs, Bike Sales --BICYCLE ... Object Fix Zip - Freeware for repairing damaged ZIP archives with ... adaptive path » 8 quick ways to fix your search engine Fix for COM Surrogate Has Stopped Working Error in Vista :: the ... Oral Fixation Mints / Get Your Fix Nail Fungus Onychomycosis - Fix My Fungus Pierre Fix-Masseau affiches sur AllPosters.fr Fixit Guide Series - DIY Mac & iPod Repair Dura Fix Aluminum Welding Aluminum Brazing Aluminum Soldering ... The Simple Dollar » 31 Days To Fix Your Finances: A Wrapup Gallery 2.2.3 Security Fix Release Gallery What To Fix VCOM: V Communications. Security, Web, OS Management, Partitioning ... Fix for securityd hogging RAM when reauthorizing apps' Keychain ... Cafe Hayek: Just Fix It DriverAgent.com Fix Your Driver Problems Instantly with Driver Agent Federal 'fix' knocks ca.gov for a loop NetworkWorld.com Community macosxhints.com - Twenty steps to help diagnose and fix system issues ca-fix program description. Fix your Exposé keys - WOW Insider IndieHIG » Blog Archive » Fix the Leopard Folders (FTLF or FTFLF) Blogger Buzz: A Layout Solution M·A·C Cosmetics Studio Fix Powder Plus Foundation The Right Way To Fix Inaccurate Wikipedia Articles The Daily Fix - WSJ.com The Art of Colin Fix Berkshire Computer Repairs And Servicing - 1-Fix Computer Services OpenBSD 3.4 errata Rob Galbraith DPI: Canon EOS-1D Mark III autofocus fix may be two ... The Hotfix - Vista SP1, XP SP3, IE8, Home Server, and more! - Home Tricia Fix Originals. Florida born fashion designer Opinion Fix public education Seattle Times Newspaper