how to fix no child left behind - time
how to fix no child left behind - time
time.com
cnn.com
search archive
home
u.s.
the page
main
politics
swampland
real clear politics
white house photo blog
world
main
the china blog
the middle east blog
blogs
main
the ag
swampland
tuned in
curious capitalist
real clear politics
work in progress
looking around
the middle east blog
nerdworld
the china blog
white house photo blog
eye on science
business & tech
main
work in progress
curious capitalist
nerdworld
health & science
main
eye on science
global warming
science of appetite
entertainment
main
tuned in
looking around
all time 100 lists
style & design
multimedia
photos
graphics
podcasts
video
magazine
table of contents
archive
covers
10 questions
specials
main
person of the year
pictures of the year
best websites
worst cars
katrina anniversary
national service
crimes of the century
cartoons of the week
pictures of the week
how to fix no child left behind
thursday, may. 24, 2007
by claudia wallis, sonja steptoe
enlarge photo left to right, third grade student, phillip armstrong, teacher, mr. kennard branch, and student, william givens take part in math explorations during class at m. hall stanton school in philadelphia, pa. in march of 2007. alex tehrani for time
article tools
print
email
reprints
sphere
rss
it's countdown time in philadelphia's public schools. just 21 days remain before the state reading and math tests in march, and the kids and faculty at james g. blaine elementary, an all-black, inner-city school that spans pre-k to eighth grade, have been drilling for much of the day. at 2:45 in the afternoon, rasheed abdullah, the kinetic lead math teacher, stages what could be called a prep rally with 11 third-graders. the kids, who are at neither the top nor the bottom of their class, have been selected for intensive review--as has a contingent from other grades--because their test scores hold the key to putting the school over the top on the pivotal pennsylvania system of school assessments (pssas). last year, after a history of failure, the school, under new leadership, managed to meet the federal goal for adequate yearly progress (ayp) on the state tests for the first time. if it does so again, blaine moves off the dreaded list of failing schools, no longer a target for intensive oversight and sanctions that could include replacing the staff.
related articles
how to bring our schools out of the 20th century
the world has changed, but the american classroom, for the most part, hasn't. now educators are starting to look at what must be done to make sure our kids make the grade in the new global economy
the myth about homework
think hours of slogging are helping your child make the grade? think again
graphic: how do children in your state test?
federal law demands testing for reading and math, but leaves it up to the states to make the tests. critics say this leads to grade inflation. are the tests in your state too easy?
abdullah, who has an easy rapport with students, issues a quick reminder to sign up for "super saturday" review classes and then begins his math-athon with a rousing recitation of the school's declaration of education. "we believe that we can learn at high levels," the children chant. "we believe we can reach our learning potential ... we believe that blaine will become a high-performing institution." quite a mouthful for an 8-year-old. and there's more. abdullah starts pumping his fists as the kids finish with passionate vows. "i'll never give up!" he shouts. "i'll never give up!" they echo. "even on the pssa test!" "even on the pssa test!" "'cause winners never lose, and i am the best!" for the next 15 minutes, the kids, divided into teams, compete to win points by solving math problems, with abdullah acting as a combination game-show host and math coach. there are giggles and cheers and plenty of correct answers, but everyone in the room knows the fate of the school is at stake. to understand the impact of the 2001 elementary and secondary education act, indelibly rebranded as no child left behind (nclb), you need to visit a school like blaine. the astonishingly ambitious law, the bush administration's proudest domestic achievement, was crafted with high-poverty, low-achieving schools like this one in mind. nclb proponents and critics alike agree that the law's greatest accomplishment has been shining an unforgiving spotlight on such languishing schools and demanding that they do better. at blaine, for instance, only 13% of fifth- and eighth-graders were reading on grade level or above in 2004--a number that has since risen to 36%. under the law's most visible stipulation, states must test public school students in reading and math every year from third through eighth grade, plus once in high school, and reveal the results for each school or face a loss of federal funds. just as critical, schools must break out test results for certain groups: blacks, hispanics, english-language learners, learning-disabled students. this has embarrassed many a top suburban school where high-flying majorities have masked the low achievement of minorities and special-ed students. the law insists--with consequences for failure--that schools make annual progress toward closing the achievement gap between rich and poor, black and white, and bring all students to grade-level proficiency in math and reading by 2014, ending what the president memorably called "the soft bigotry of low expectations." ask almost any school administrator, education policymaker or think-tank wonk about nclb, and you're guaranteed to get at least one sunny metaphor about how the law opened a window, raised a curtain or otherwise illuminated the plight of the nation's underserved kids. this is nclb's biggest achievement and the best reason for congress to reauthorize the law. "at the end of the day, who can argue with holding schools accountable for all children?" asks paul vallas, outgoing chief executive of philadelphia's schools and incoming head of the new orleans school district. "who can argue with not tolerating failing schools or with giving poor kids the kinds of choices that wealthier kids have? it's a civil rights issue." there's plenty of argument, however, about how the law seeks to achieve these goals. nclb takes the federal government--which contributes only 9¢ of every $1 spent on u.s. schools--where it's never gone before: telling the states how to measure school success, specifying interventions for failure, mandating qualifications for teachers and even telling the nation how to teach reading. this year, as the five-year-old law comes up for debate, an unforgiving spotlight will be focused on its impact thus far, including its numerous unintended consequences. many teachers are enraged by the law's reliance on high-stakes exams that lead schools like blaine to focus relentlessly on boosting scores rather than pursuing a broader vision of education. more than 30,000 educators and concerned citizens have signed an online petition calling for the repeal of the 1,100-page statute. some offer comments like this one from a former superintendent of schools in ohio: "nclb is like a russian novel. that's because it's long, it's complicated, and in the end, everybody gets killed." whether nclb is achieving its objectives remains an open question. fourth-grade reading scores on the national assessment of educational progress (naep) rose sharply from 1999 to 2004, but most of the gains occurred before the law took effect. the achievement gap appears to be narrowing in some spots--fourth- and eighth-grade math scores for minorities, for instance--but not others. the gap between white and black eighth-graders has widened slightly in math, for example. gains for eighth-graders in general remain stubbornly elusive. secretary of education margaret spellings, who has been advising the president on education since his days as texas governor, notes that the law went into full effect only last year and that more time is needed for it to work. still, she and the administration have proposed a large number of adjustments to a law she once compared to ivory soap, saying "it's 99.9% pure." "we wrote the very best bill we could five years ago," spellings told time, "but we've learned from our experiences." meanwhile, members of congress have their own fix-it agendas, as do state education officials and, of course, the teachers unions. much of the debate over renewing the law is focused on five areas of controversy: •ayp on reading and math tests: is it the right tool for measuring learning and raising achievement in the nation's schools?
page 1 of 4
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
| next >>
top stories
photoexclusive pics: inside bhutto's 'prison'
sicily's mafia: life after decapitation
behind the alicia keys myspace scam
most popular
most emailed
behind the alicia keys myspace scam
the dinosaur conspiracy theoryadhd kids can get betterthe race to be the un-hillarybehind the king's rebuke to chávezcan obama rock the nomination?veterans' day vandals touch a nervewhen the patient is a googlerpope to skip boston in us tour
rapper kanye west's mother dies
adhd kids can get better
behind the alicia keys myspace scam
the dinosaur conspiracy theory
when the patient is a googler
mellowing out on marijuana
in search of superman's inner jew
the great uncircumcision debate
behind the king's rebuke to chávez
iraq, afghan war cost: $1 trillion
the power of birth order
see complete list
get this in your email
you will need to install or upgrade your flash player to be able to view this flash content. also, javascript must be turned on.
grab it! to put quotes of the day on your personal page or blog
features
| click arrows to view more features
more features
world
are iraq's detainees treated fairly?
world
forgiving the lord's resistance army
doctor's view
when surgery succeeds, but healing fails
surgeons take it for granted that skin will heal after we cut it. once in a while, however, that doesn't happen
ask your questions
novelist umberto eco
nation
a-rod's salary: watching for collusion
science
need to weed your roof?
humor
cartoons of the week
arts
rhett, we hardly knew ye
world
arafat rally sparks gaza violence
arts
in search of superman's inner jew
quick links:
u.s.|world|blogs|business & tech|health & science|entertainment|photos|magazine|specials|archive
rss feeds|get time on your mobile device|podcasts|video|newsletter
services:
subscribe | |help|site map|contact us||terms of use|media kit|reprints & permissions|opinion leaders panel
editions:
time domestic|time europe|time asia|time south pacific|time for kids
time.com
copyright © 2007 time inc. all rights reserved.
reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
alex tehrani for time
left to right, third grade student, phillip armstrong, teacher, mr. kennard branch, and student, william givens take part in math explorations during class at m. hall stanton school in philadelphia, pa. in march of 2007.
close
Acceuil
suivante
how to fix no child left behind - time Film Fix v1.0 JScreenFix - Fix stuck pixels and screen burn-in Mac OS X and iPod Troubleshooting, Support, and Help - MacFixIt Braun 1775 FREE Control /FIX 100 : avis de consommateurs ... Macworld: News: Word fix corrects quit on print error Macworld: Mac 911: Bugs & Fixes: Fix Leopard glitches Housse Sit Fix pour coussin 3 en 1, Housse Sit Fix - Fnac éveil et ... Blagojevich floats new temporary fix :: CHICAGO SUN-TIMES ... Here's hoping fix is in :: CHICAGO SUN-TIMES :: Mike Mulligan Fix-it Index Page Functions, events, club, bar, lounge, entertainment, Venues ... Fix the Fells - Home Excel Recovery Tool - Fix & Repair Excel File - Corrupt XLS Repair ... Fast Fix Jewelry and Watch Repairs B2BITS — High Performance FIX Solutions Definition: fix from Online Medical Dictionary Télécharger Object Fix Zip - Zebulon.fr : téléchargement du ... Aimfix - Jayloden.com BBC SPORT Tennis Llodra reveals match-fix approach BBC NEWS Science/Nature Lovelock urges ocean climate fix Growing a Business Website: Fix the Basics First (Jakob Nielsen's ... 6 Ways to Fix a Confused Information Architecture (Jakob Nielsen's ... Definition of fix - Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary ColdFusion MX 7 Cumulative Hot Fix 3 ColdFusion 8.0 Cumulative Hot Fix 1 FixMyXP.com - Your One Stop Windows XP Fix It Site Télécharger Works Fix réseau pc fix(usb) portable wifi - je ne trouve pas les config ... Fix the pumps Intel Researcher Homepage Mandriva: Updated netpbm packages fix vulnerability - The ... Debian: New phpmyadmin packages fix cross-site scripting - The ... SubZero Fix PSTwo - : FOXCHIP : Modification et Réparation des ... GRC FIX-CIH Virus Recovery IEBlog : Fix My Settings in IE7 Let's Fix britain The Beyonce Fix Intro.... The new urgency to fix online privacy Tech News on ZDNet Macworld: News: Apple releases fix for iMac freezing issue Macworld: News: Apple posts QuickTime security fix SmitFraudFix QuickFix: Open Source FIX Engine Free Registry Fix - Fix My Registry Candy- Chocolate- A Candy Fix Lettres édifiantes et curieuses, écrites des missions étrangères. - Résultats Google Recherche de Livres Water fix proposed in Southeast - Weather - MSNBC.com OpenBSD 4.0 errata Reviews: Video Game Reviews Are Broken, Please Fix System Downloads : DHCP Fix /// AnalogX How to fix broken Firefox extensions Free Software Magazine molly.com » So How Do We Fix the Web, Really? PKH-fix - Prozeßkostenhilfeberechnung macosxhints.com - 10.5: A fix for broken video chats and screen ... Acheter Housse pouf Sit Fix... avec eco-SAPIENS MacNN Apple updates iMac fix for Tiger users MacNN Apple updates iMac fix for Tiger users Madeleine Fix-Hansen :: Design :: Illustration :: Media ... How not to fix HTML ¶ Personal Weblog of Joe Clark, Toronto Histoire philosophique et politique des établissemens et du ... - Résultats Google Recherche de Livres Markdown Fix