two tales of one city - haaretz - israel news
two tales of one city - haaretz - israel news
subscribe to print edition
|
thu., january 25, 2007 shvat 6, 5767
|
|
israel time: 21:59 (est+7)
search site
back to homepage
print edition
diplomacy
defense
opinion
national
arts & leisure
anglo file
sports
travel
magazine
week's end
q&a
business
underground
jewish world
real estate
advertising
bookmark to del.icio.us
two tales of one city
by aryeh dayan
there is something sad and perhaps even pathetic about the way muhammad abu aisha pulls out the old and wrinkled paper he always keeps in one of the pockets of his clothing. he lives on the second floor of the house surrounded by a metal screen that is across from the jewish settlers' compound in tel rumeida in hebron, and he is the grandfather of rajaa abu aisha, the young woman of 19 who lives in the same building and who made headlines this week in the wake of the short film she made. in it, her neighbor, israeli settler yifat alkobi, is seen cursing her again and again. the paper that abu aisha keeps in his pocket, and which he hastened to display this week to everyone who visited his home, is a faded photocopy of a page of "the hebron book," a deluxe album that was published at the start of the 1970s in order to perpetuate the memory of the jewish community that lived in the town until the massacre in 1929. even though he does not read hebrew, he knows very well what is written on the page, an account of those among the arabs of hebron who risked their lives to save their jewish neighbors. at the bottom of the page is a blurred photograph of two men embracing. "this is ya'akov ezra and this is my father, hamed abu aisha," says the elderly man. at the beginning of the 1980s, he relates, dr. yosef burg, who was then interior minister, and whose wife was born in hebron, visited the town. according to abu aisha, burg "told the settlers that they must not harm the abu aisha family, because everyone knows that members of the family saved jews. but burg departed and left us with baruch marzel."
advertisement
yifat alkobi and rajaa abu aisha, the two women who gained momentary fame thanks to the repulsive film that set the country on edge this week, are clear representatives of the communities to which they belong. the jewish settlement mustered behind alkobi, while abu aisha became the heroine of the day for the palestinians in hebron and the west bank, as well as many on the israeli left. their tale is not just a story of two neighbors at odds, but rather and primarily the story of the impossible reality that has developed in hebron as a result of the presence of the jewish settlers in the heart of the palestinian city. the abu aisha family's home, surrounded by a metal screen and looking more like a cage now than a residence, can be understood as the symbol of this reality. the curses that alkobi hured at her neighbor on the other side of the metal screen are the soundtrack of this film. muhammad abu aisha, who is 72 and now lives on the second floor of the house with his wife, who is younger than him by 20 years, and their three small children, built this house back in the days of jordanian rule. during the first decade of israeli rule, after 1967, the family did not experience any unusual incidents, and also after 1982, when the first settlers came to tel rumeida, the abu aishas continued to live undisturbed. "in the beginning we even had good relations with the jewish neighbors," he relates. "i would bring them peaches and grapes from my orchard and my vineyard and they also related to us well." the problems started later this idyllic reality began to change during the course of the 1980s, as the number of settlers increased and their age changed. "at first," relates abu aisha, "there were mature people here, who were like the jews who lived in hebron until 1929. the problems started later, when the older people left and in their stead people like baruch marzel and noam federman came," he said, referring to the two right-wing extremists who have had frequent run-ins with the law for attacks on their palestinian neighbors, among other things. he had to erect the dense metal screen in 1996, when stones hurled at the windows of his home became a daily phenomenon. rima abu aisha, his daughter-in-law, who lives with her family on the house's first floor, says that ever since the mid-1990s, every exit from the house has become a real danger for her seven children. "in the morning i send them to school only after i see that the vehicle that takes the settler children to school has already left the neighborhood," she relates. "if our children leave the house while the settler children are still waiting in the street for their vehicle, my children will be the targets of stone-throwing and spitting." in the afternoon, at the end of the school day, she goes up on the roof and does surveillance of the surroundings. if she sees a clustering of settler children, she phones her sister-in-law, whose house is along the route of her children's return from school, and asks her to wait for them and bring them into her home until the settler children have passed. they have been living this way for many years now. about two years ago her daughter rajaa told an investigator for b'tselem, the israeli information center for human rights in the territories, that her father had bought bicycles for her brothers but they do not dare use them outside for fear of the settler children. instead, they ride inside the house, in a large room where from time to time their mother moves the furniture aside for that purpose. "it pains me when i see the settlers' children playing soccer and happily riding bikes under our house, with soldiers protecting them," she said in her testimony in 2005. "we can't do that, and all the time we're looking at them enviously through the window. we even have a problem with their games. my father bought ashraf [her brother] a soccer ball. one of the soldiers came into our house and said that the ball wasn't ours and that it belonged to the settlers' children. the soldier took the ball from ashraf and gave it to the [settler] children. my brothers can't even buy toy rifles because this is prohibited. to tell the truth," she continued in her testimony, "there isn't anyone in my family whom the settlers haven't attacked." this week her grandfather displayed a plastic bag, in which he keeps copies of more than 20 complaints against the neighbors that he and his family have submitted to the police. in most of the complaints the subject is listed as "assault." in a few, it is stated as "curses," "spitting" or "violent behavior." he relates that "every time we complain, the police demand that we say exactly who attacked us, what his name is, what he looks like, what the color of his eyes is, what shape of skullcap he has and what his father's name is. if we can't answer all of those questions, they don't deal with the complaint." and indeed nearly all the files that the police have opened in the wake of their complaints were closed after a short time. this is not exceptional or unusual. from data gathered by b'tselem, it emerges that in 2005, 176 complaints against settlers were submitted to the hebron police. of the cases that were opened in the wake of the complaints, 87 were closed immediately, and in 43 of the cases it emerged that the acts were committed by minors who had not yet reached the age of criminal responsibility. only in five cases did the police recommend filing an indictment. the figures relating to the first 10 months of 2006 show that during that period, the police dealt with 352 incidents of settler violence, and that only in 27 of them did it recommend filing indictments. two of the four palestinian families who lived adjacent to the settlers in tel rumeida got fed up with this reality and abandoned their homes. the members of the abu aisha family, on whose front door settlers painted a large star of david, see this as a declaration of intentions and are convinced that the aim is to cause them to leave as well. muhammad abu aisha promises that he will not leave his home. "they don't understand that as long as i am living here, they are protected," he says. "allah and his prophet muhammad command me to protect my neighbors, and i really do tell palestinians in other parts of hebron that they should not harm my neighbors, even though they harm me. the moment i am no longer here, they will be exposed to attacks." this could happen anywhere the wall of the settlers' compound is less than five meters away from the screen surrounding the abu aisha family's home. there they see a different reality and present an opposite picture, according to which they, the settlers, are victims of organized palestinian violence and also of an israeli law-enforcement system that time and again is deceived by an efficient propaganda machine, in which are partners palestinians, international organizations and elements from israel. david wilder, a hebron resident who serves as the spokesman to the foreign media for the jewish settlement in the town, claimed this week, in an interview with cnn, that "the alkobi affair" is nothing but an ordinary dispute between neighbors, "of the sort that could also happen in the united states or japan." it has been exploited, wilder added, by a coalition of leftist israeli and international organizations, to shame the hebron settlers and damage the legitimacy of their presence in the town. he also claimed that the palestinians who eight years ago killed rabbi shlomo ra'anan succeeded in penetrating ra'anan's home in tel rumeida, thanks to "prior information" provided to them by "the arab inhabitants of the neighborhood." like muhammad abu aisha, wilder tells of the decent neighborly relations that once prevailed in tel rumeida. one member of the abu aisha family, a carpenter by trade, once repaired a broken chair for one of the settlers and refused to accept payment. "it seemed as though the days of the messiah had come," says wilder. "children from the two families, jewish and arab, started playing together." abu aisha, incidentally, confirms the story of the chair but says that there had never been friendly relations among the children. wilder asserts that the friendship between the jewish and the palestinian children ended when a quarrel broke out between them. children quarrel everywhere in the world, but what it led to here, according to wilder, was different from what happens in other places. in the wake of the quarrel, a member of the abu aisha family came to the home of the setter family and yelled for a long time at the woman who opened the door to him. "a soldier who was there asked the woman of the house whether she wanted to file a complaint about the man who shouted," he relates, "and she answered him that she did not understand arabic and that she had no idea what he was saying. the soldier said to her that he did understand arabic, and that the man had said that he intended to come back with a knife and kill all of them. of course the children stopped playing together." wilder says that this was the start of the quarrel that led to yifat alkobi's curses. it was only the continuation of the quarrel that had a political context, according to him. "about a year and a half ago," wilder explains, "groups of arab extremists got organized, headed by an arab-palestinian organization that is funded by the european union, and together with other organizations, like anarchists against the wall, they decided to focus on the tel rumeida neighborhood, with the aim of causing as much disorder as possible, so that they would be able to blame 'the monstrous jews.'" he claims that activists of the foreign organizations "are inciting against the security forces" and fomenting "provocations against civilians, in an attempt to draw adults, youths and children into violent situations, which they film in a very selective way and distribute on sites on the internet." thus, he says, was created the short film in which alkobi appears. "what happened? what do you see in the film?" wilder asks, with the aim of playing down the conflict that is seen there. "one woman is shouting at another woman. is this material for a news headline? for a reaction from the prime minister?" he acknowledges that "her language was not all that refined," but is convinced that there was no justification for the uproar that the film caused. only a few dozen shops remain however, a short visit to tel rumeida and its environs suffices to confirm that what is happening there is very far from an ordinary dispute between neighbors, and that the policy implemented by the israel defense forces in areas where settlers live has led, in fact, to the demise of palestinian life in the area. the idf prohibits the palestinian families living there from moving around the area in vehicles, a prohibition that extends as well to other quarters of hebron where settlers live. and palestinians from other neighborhoods, or from outside hebron altogether, are prohibited by the idf from entering these areas even by foot. thus total social isolation has been imposed on the palestinians who still reside in areas around the settlers' houses. the city was divided in the 1998 hebron agreement. most of it was handed over to the full responsibility of the palestinian authority, but israel retained security responsibilty for a small part of it, where today some 400 jewish settlers and about 30,000 palestinians live. this part of hebron, which surrounds the tomb of the patriarchs, was until 1998 the commercial and social heart of palestinian hebron. for decades, the casbah, which is adjacent to the tomb of the patriarchs, and the streets around it constituted a huge market that supported thousands of families and provided varied services to the villages of the entire large rural area surrounding hebron. all this died out entirely in the wake of the prohibitions on movement that the idf has imposed in recent years. in the casbah, where in the past many hundreds of shops had been active, only a very few dozen remain. in the afternoon hours of thursday of this week, for example, the lanes of the casbah were nearly deserted with only a few shoppers moving among the small number of shops that have not yet been abandoned. the scene outside the casbah, in the huge commercial area that used to surround the buildings where the setters live, is much bleaker. the entire quarter, which is comprised of many streets that until about a decade ago were vibrant and lively and thronged with people, has become a ghost town, which looks as though it is a cardboard movie set. the thousands of shops, workshops, offices and business centers that were active there for decades and formed the center of hebron have been abandoned and closed. cars do not travel on the roads, pedestrians do not walk on the sidewalks and the glass in the windows in the upper stories of the buildings is shattered. the gas station has been dismantled and it too is abandoned. only a few faded signs that have not yet been ripped out testify to what had been there in the past. next to beit romano, one of the settlers' buildings in the town, it is possible to make out, for example, the sign that dr. muhammad tamimi, general practitioner, hung at the entrance to his clinic to announce his reception hours. further along the street, one can still see the sign of the halil al rahman travel agency, which specialized in organizing pilgrimage trips to mecca. not far from there is the sign of the pharmacy that was managed by dr. idris al keisi. across from there, on the iron door of what was once the office of the al andalus taxi stand, it now says, in big, black hebrew letters: "death to the arabs."
bookmark to del.icio.us
someplace like home
recently israel has witnessed a boom of small hotels, each with its own unique charm.
free cell
new companies are planning to offer technologies that will reduce our cell phone bills.
1.
arab violence brought demise of hebron arabs` commercial center
13:20
|
yishai kohen
19/01/07
2.
dayan`s desperate deceitful drivel
13:26
|
joshua
19/01/07
3.
bad article- good responces
15:32
|
margarita
19/01/07
4.
one sided article
16:41
|
reuven
19/01/07
5.
if i landed from mars and read this story...
16:58
|
bat yam
19/01/07
6.
hebron
17:01
|
eg
19/01/07
7.
very good article - bad responses
17:30
|
tony jansen
19/01/07
8.
the costs of religious fanaticism
19:00
|
lori
19/01/07
9.
hebron a `palestinian` city?
19:54
|
s
19/01/07
10.
#8
20:11
|
gili
19/01/07
11.
#9 s
20:38
|
boycott
19/01/07
12.
what for?
20:40
|
alon
19/01/07
13.
hebron and the bible
20:59
|
kevin
19/01/07
14.
the problem with your explanation no. 5
13:22
|
marlene
20/01/07
15.
you forgot one thing aryeh
13:25
|
marlene
20/01/07
today online
to attack or not to attack iran, that is the question
responses: 270
draft deferrals for yeshiva students surpass 50,000 mark
responses: 86
international donors give over $7 billion in aid for lebanon
responses: 99
aluf benn: taking the opportunity to get rid of the presidency
responses: 23
israel must purge the corruption from its immune system
responses: 46
more headlines
21:12
fm: palestinian state is achievable, not an illusion
19:19
knesset house committee okays katsav's request for suspension
21:04
hamas: one killed, eight hurt in gaza strip roadside bombing
21:25
at least two killed in student clashes at a beirut university
20:17
17-year-old given life sentence for 2005 murder of rehovot teen
20:17
omri sharon appeals jail term, requests community service
21:35
italy approves law making holocaust denial a crime
15:37
international donors pledge over $7 billion for lebanon government
14:35
katsav accuser sues presidential aide for slander
15:04
settlers to peretz: improve gov't attitude toward our communities
previous editions
select day
24 jan
23 jan
22 jan
21 jan
19 jan
18 jan
17 jan
16 jan
15 jan
14 jan
12 jan
11 jan
special offers
advertisement
skin care products
shop high-class skin care cosmetics with dead sea minerals. coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
join free at jdate.com
the most popular online jewish dating community in the world! explore the possibilities! click here!
camp kimama israel
israel's international summer camps!
learn hebrew online
learn hebrew from the best teachers in israel live over the internet
home|
print edition|
diplomacy|
opinion|
arts & leisure|
sports|
jewish world|
underground|
site rules|
© copyright haaretz. all rights reserved
Acceuil
suivante
two tales of one city - haaretz - israel news
allmovie ((( All new DVD releases > All New > Feature ))) M6 - SEMAINE 43 2006 PROGRAMMES DU SAMEDI 21 AU VENDREDI 27 ... The Vulcanization of the Human Brain: A Neural Perspective on ... Layout 1 (Page 1) diskothiq Peter Peter Hughes ... Upcoming Shows at Crystal Ballroom - Portland Music Calendar ... TV and the Internet: Pitfalls in Forecasting the Future Diários de Motocicleta LOVEFiLM: User collections - An Anthropologist's ... Seznam novosti oktober 2005 ESSENGER NQUIRER Reit- und Fahrverein Dülken-Viersen: Nennungen Winterturnier 2005 du Nord: June 2006 TURKISH REMIX REMIXES MP3 VIDEO YUKLEME COMMUNITY prologue DVD Movies Library,Download in DVD, DivX, iPod quality ... Listology: My favorite movies, Top 1000 SeyrediyoruM.Com Popüler Kültür şarkı sözleri DAD’S ARMY, THE COMPLETE FIRST SERIES PLUS THE ‘LOST’ EPISODES OF ... THE HIGH HAT CONTRIBUTORS Interactivist Info Exchange International Action Center - "Peace ... CINE: DVD y VIDEO Critical Care Medicine - Fulltext: Volume 33(1) January 2005 p 270 ... Jewish Film Archive Online Titres diffusés commencant par la lettre D - Page 3 - Fluctuat.net Shishi OPFOR: February 2007 Archives Donating - Donor Recognition Sex lies and 6 o’clock news « Frontier Former Editor × [ .. مملكه القلوب , حين يصبح عالم ... MVlib - UK:PG certificated movies Daniel in Brookline: September 2006 Movies tagged with the "museum" keyword - The Movie Library ... Foreign Press Review Foreign Press Review Untitled Video » Тусни нет - скачать бесплатно mp3, софт, обои, игры ... New York Foundation for the Arts (NYFA) grubi - Profile Haber Kuşağı / Doğru Haber Dürüst Yorum The Count of Monte Cristo (2002) Vanderbilt News Service Pacific Law Center = BAD FAITH = Solomon Ward Attorneys INDEX 247 <a href="http://www.cambridge.org">© Cambridge ... Family Movies Lib Program_tv - Wirtualna Polska News - Luglio 2006 Verfasser Standort Titel Buchungsnr ... und dann kam Polly DVD U ... Edgar Allan Poe’s (Meta)physics: A Pre-History of the Post-Human Blackwell Synergy - Dermatol Surg, Volume 25 Issue 6 Page 440-444 ... The One Hundred Seventy-fifth Commencement Exercises AboutFilm.Com - The Films of 2003 (page 1) Anexo:Lista dos personagens de 24 Horas - Wikipédia allmovie ((( Re-Issues > Re-Issues > Feature ))) Virrey de Mendoza en lajaula.net Minor League Players Born on February 10 - Baseball-Reference.com La Passione di Cristo Why Aren't They Talking About Ho Yeow Sun? Sell Timeshare >> Sell My Time Share Now 8506 Annual TXT artforum.com / DIARY